©
WASHINGTON
A federal judge Thursday severely limited the Navy's ability to use midfrequency sonar on a training range off the southern California coast, ruling that the loud sounds would harm whales and other marine mammals if not tightly controlled.
The decision is a blow to the Navy, which has argued that it needs the flexibility to train its sonar operators without undue restrictions. In her decision, District Judge Florence-Marie Cooper said the Navy could conduct productive training under the limitations, which she said were required under several environmental laws.
Cooper banned the use of the sonar within 12 nautical miles of the California coast, expanded from 1,100 yards to 2,200 yards the Navy's proposed "shut down" zone in which sonar must be turned off whenever a marine mammal is spotted, and required monitoring for animals before and during exercises.
Navy spokeswoman Cindy Moore said the Navy was reviewing the ruling.
Active sonar has been used for decades to detect submarines, but marine specialists began to connect mass strandings of whales with the loud sound blasts only a decade ago.
The plaintiff in the lawsuit, National Resources Defense Council, has also criticized the Navy's plan for a sonar training range off the North Carolina coast. The Navy is conducting an environmental analysis of the proposed 625-square-mile range, where Norfolk-based ships would practice hunting subs.
Critics claimed the Navy's initial assessment in 2005 of the possible damage to mammals was cursory, and its plans to mitigate harm were deficient.
Michael Jasny, a senior policy analyst for NRDC, said the California ruling is sure to affect the North Carolina proposal. "The court finds the existing standard mitigation scheme is woefully inadequate, and this would be true virtually regardless of where they're operating," Jasny said. He said the council will keep pressure on the Navy.
Virginian-Pilot staff writer Kate Wiltrout contributed to this report.
Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Facebook
Twitter
Google
Yahoo
Oh brother!
While the defenders of America's freedom are once again put in a position of denied practice we can rest easily because the whales are safe.
Navy Sonar
About time someone stood up to the Navy lies about SONAR not being harmful to our marine life. All the BS about the trade offs of protecting our submarines (need trainging) and killing marine life. Enough said.
Good News For China
The flawed and biased decision of Judge Cooper comes with a price...the degradation of our nation's anti-submarine capabilities. What are her credentials with regard to determining national security requirments? NONE! At least she can feel snug and comfy under the sheets as she jumps in bed with the NRDC. As far as the NRDC goes, it does nothing more than provide jobs to attorneys who really are nothing more than extreme left wing policy wonks who line their pockets with cash from the Hollywood elitists. I'm curious, will Judge Cooper and the NRDC be willing to accept responsibilty for their actions and decisions when we are no longer capable of detecting and neutralizing shallow water diesel submarine threats? They do exist you know. The whole environmental movement has gotten completely out of hand. Sorry Flipper, sonar is bad for you but good for me....PING AWAY!