The Virginian-Pilot
©
NEWPORT NEWS
State officials have approved another measure to protect blue crabs in the Chesapeake Bay by limiting their harvest, a move that comes on the heels of several other dramatic rules enacted this year in Virginia waters.
Under the latest regulation, approved late Tuesday by the Virginia Marine Resources Commission, more than 800 watermen will not be allowed to renew their crabbing licenses in 2009 - and for at least three years after that - if they did not catch crabs from 2004 to 2007.
The new rule is intended to freeze those 800 or so licenses, which have gone unused during the four-year baseline period.
The idea is to ensure that, if crabs stocks rebound as scientists expect, a sudden gold rush of fishing activity will not occur and wipe away gains made from other conservation steps adopted this year.
"We're not taking anyone's license away. We're just putting them on hold," Rick Robins, a commission member, told an anxious crowd of watermen during a marathon meeting Tuesday in Newport News.
Those watermen affected by the freeze can reapply for their licenses, but only after crab populations stay at a sustainable level for three straight years after 2009, officials explained.
The state has set that safe level at 200 million juvenile crabs in the Bay; the current population in Virginia and Maryland waters is about 120 million youngsters, according to scientific estimates.
There are exceptions to the new licensing rule, however.
A waterma n could continue crabbing next year by purchasing the license of someone else who is leaving the fishery and transferring it.
Or, between 5 and 10 percent of those watermen on the freeze list could appeal to the state for a special permit that would allow them to catch a limited number of crabs during the season.
According to state statistics, the freeze will hit 524 watermen who hold licenses for harvesting hard crabs with a pot, or trap, and 343 individuals who use peeler pots for catching soft crabs.
The action Tuesday is likely the last one Virginia will impose this year to benefit ailing crab stocks.
Alarmed by a decade-long decline in crabs in the Bay, the governors of Virginia and Maryland agreed to jointly cut harvests of female crabs by 34 percent this year. Without such action, the leaders feared a collapse of the Bay's most famous seafood species.
Virginia so far has limited the crabbing season by several weeks, set pot limits, required additional escape rings in pots, and closed the winter dredge fishery for the first time in more than 100 years.
That fishery, which relies on a heavy steel rake dragged behind a work boat, captures mostly pregnant female crabs. They are hibernating on the muddy bottom of the Bay, often in waters off Norfolk, Virginia Beach and the Eastern Shore.
The restrictions, along with the fragile stocks, led the federal government to declare the Bay crab fishery a national disaster this year. Congress has approved $10 million in aid to hundreds of Virginia watermen suffering for lack of work.
Ernie Bowden, a Chincoteague waterman and voting member of the state marine commission, said he "could live with" the license freeze, though he thinks it will do little good in the long term.
Even if 200 million juveniles are present after three years of protection, Bowden said, "there'll be no place to sell the crabs," given that processors are on the verge of going out of business already.
"I hope this all works, believe me," Bowden said. "I just think there's too many forces working against us."
Scott Harper, (757) 446-2340, scott.harper@pilotonline.com

Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Facebook
Twitter
Google
Yahoo

Bad Water 2008 Report CBF
Not to beat a dead horse here, but to those who don't believe the waters are in trouble, check out the yearly report from the Chesapeake Bay Foundation, compiled by scientists and other organizations: cbf.org/badwater2008
The crab populations have been in a constant decline over the past few years and numbers are really hurting, consistently falling below what scientists consider necessary to maintain a healthy crab population. Further regulations regarding pollution need to follow these crabbing regulations though, because overharvesting is only half the problem!
It's the pollution not the crabbing!
I wouldn't eat ANYTHING that came from the sludge of the Chesapeake! YUKKO!! It's the pollution that's killing the crabbing, not the crabbers--but the bay still needs to let the crabs try to recover. I don't see it happening judging from the STENCH of the water and the rainbow haze of oil and other pollutants floating on top of the water! You couldn't PAY me to eat anthing that comes from that sludge!
New Jobs
I love the unsympathetic comments being made about the waterman. They are selfish at best. To tell people that live on Tangier Island to go make new careers for themselves is the most idiotic statement yet. They are doing what has been passed down to them generation after generation. It is the only means most of them have to make a living. Most of you will most likely be the first to whine when you have to pay twenty dollars for a couple of crab cakes. The real solution to saving the bay is not beating up on the waterman but taking some painful steps towards enviromental protection. It would start with developements along the shorelines and extend to discharges into the bay as well as clamping down on recreational boaters.This of course, would hurt revenues to localities and we can't have that. Most experts admit that there are dead spots in the bay that are devoid of marine life and it is not from crabbing, its from pollution and runoffs of nutrients from farms and lawns. I am glad Kaine is on the way out. He is the worst governor Virginia has seen in decades.
A Better Headline
Perhaps the headline for this article should have been "800 Virginia waterman could temporarily lose unused crabbing licenses".
Continued Depletion of Resource Cannot be Sustained
The action to restrict license holders is just one facet of the jewel of resource protection, not the intentional targeting of woeful crabbers. The crabbers blame land-lubber pollution for their woes. The enviros blame crabbers for over-harvesting a depleting resource. Who is right/wrong and who really cares? Dredging hibernating crabs with eggs is shortsighted when resource sustainability is concerned. Having worked in several fish markets, dredged crabs are of poor quality and often wrecked to the point where they were not marketable. Crabs burdened with eggs have little umph left for a high quality meat, and mud and sand do not help the product. Between the poor quality meat, the nature-designed period of seasonal rest, and the presence of next seasons' bounty in the form of busted sooks, who in their right mind would intentionally deplete the resource by dredging. Dredging is a cause of resource ruination be it grass beds, habitable bottom, or taking of nursery crabs. Foster the resource and it will rebound beyond expectation.
Watermen
They go the same place as all the others unemployed....to find another job and stop belly-aching! I didn't see them crying when the auto workers, textile workers, airline workers and thousands of others were unemployed. The watermen are not special to anyone other than the watermen...a legend in their oun mind.
There is a problem you're
There is a problem you're overlooking, and it's very serious. This is another government move to over-regulate industry. Have we forgotten about this problem in the age of entitlement? Government regulation of industry requires overhead, meaning the taxpayers pay for it. Any theoretical population rebound, as the Commonwealth believes may occur, could be overharvested by a small number of busy licenses, so the license hold just amounts to greater government control over the private sector. This problematic aspect will be poo-poo'ed by those accustomed to public school, government retirement, and government health care, but it is very serious in its reflection of a progression.
Traveler
I was in the Trucking business for over 20 years. Major contracts were lost. Things got tough. I changed careers. People have done this for years if not centuries. Watermen are not the only folks with problems and setbacks.
The Blue Crabs are being hit hard from many angles. If we don't take serious measures now, there won't be any left in the future.
POINTS
All great comments; smart folks here.
Where do the Watermen go now?
Crabs Plentiful?
I had to post in regards to the thought that " crabs are plentiful ". Having grown up on the eastern shore of MD, I have first hand knowledge of what the waterman use to haul in not even 15-20 years ago. Several friends of the family and distant family members live off the upper part of the Chesapeake Bay, which is much different then down here. Currently I work for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service on the Currituck sound and have current and very reliable information regarding populations in and around the bay. My roommate from college, who works for MD DNR, is the person responsible for doing the crab survey every year for the state of MD. I and he can tell you, the crabs are NOT plentiful. Havent been for almost 10 years. Big difference what people will say when their way of life is challenged by outsiders. These restrictions, while unfortunate now, will save the industry and provide viable harvests for our children and hopefully their children. Crabs are NOT plentiful.