The Virginian-Pilot
©
What I'm about to say may sound sarcastic. But it's not.
I love Virginia. Especially the General Assembly.
Oh, I may not be fond of every single member of the state legislature - heck, I don't know most of them - but a few are undeniably lovable. Del. Lionell Spruill comes to mind. And Del. Bob Tata.
Legislating teddy bears, both.
As best I can tell, most members of the Richmond crowd are hard working, part-time citizen lawmakers, unconcerned with what the rest of the country thinks of them.
What do you say we give them a little credit for such independence?
There have been several Very Virginia Bills passed by one chamber or the other recently that might not get a second outside of the Old Dominion.
One was the restaurant smoking ban that passed the House of Delegates this week and caused steam to pour out of the governor's ears.
As most of us know, Gov. Tim Kaine wants to ban smoking in every Virginia restaurant. Never mind that most eateries (how I hate that word and use it only to avoid restauranting everyone to death) are already smoke-free.
You see, restaurateurs have learned that few people smoke, so banning cigarettes is good for business. In time there will be only a handful of smoking establishments left in the commonwealth.
Yet an impatient army of anti-smoking zealots - led by the governor - continue to stomp their feet and demand a law that would outlaw smoking in every restaurant. Now.
It's for the children! they sometimes cry.
So the House of Delegates cleverly tossed a bone to anti-smoking activists with a bill that would allow smoking in restaurants if most minors aren't allowed in or if there is a door between the smoking and non smoking sides.
The governor isn't happy about it. Neither are those who want Virginia to be more like, well, New York.
But the common-sense crowd in the Old Dominion long ago figured out that if you don't want a side order of smoke with your meal, you shouldn't patronize restaurants that allow smoking.
That gets easier every day, by the way.
Another bill that would give some New Yorkers a case of the vapors would allow concealed-carry permit holders to bring their weapons into restaurants, provided they didn't drink alcohol.
Virginians can already open-carry a gun into an eatery. Why not a holstered weapon?
Last time I checked, those with concealed-carry permits were not shooting up Virginia's bars. (Oops. Almost forgot, Virginia doesn't have bars. We have eateries that serve alcohol.)
Which brings us to those creeps who are shooting up the place.
The General Assembly has something for them this year, too. It's the proposed change of the triggerman rule - although the governor, an opponent of capital punishment, has promised to veto it.
That bill says if you are part of a killing enterprise and manage to get one of your dim witted companions to pull the trigger, the state may put you out of your misery along with the person who was holding the weapon.
So, while other states abandon the death penalty, the Virginia General Assembly defiantly tries to expand it.
More proof - if any was needed - of a stubborn streak of independence in many Virginia lawmakers.
Kerry Dougherty, (757) 446-2306, kerry.dougherty@cox.net

Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Facebook
Twitter
Google
Yahoo
this quote says it all
"Yet an impatient army of anti-smoking zealots - led by the governor - continue to stomp their feet and demand a law that would outlaw smoking in every restaurant."
This quote from Kerry's article sums it all.
People (non-smokers) need to get a life and find something esle to complain about like open carry guns, which is more insaine than I can say.
public/private
the difference between a car and a restaurant: If I own a restaurant, I want you to come in and spend your money. If I'm driving my car, I DONT want you inside with me
Well I do know the
Well I do know the difference between private and public. But I own a car, yet I am obligated by public safety to obey the rules for driving. So it would be if I owned a restaurant; that is, I must observe certain rules and regulations on preparing and storing food in order to promote public health. I believe that the same can be said for rules relating to air quality in places used by the public. We now know that the introduction of nicotine and smoke in a public space has serious and negative health consequences for those who inhale it. So it is fully within our concept of representative democracy to adopt rules to regulate air quality as we do for food preparation and for safe driving. Do we give up a bit of our liberty? Yes, or course, but that is the only way for citizens to live together in society.
Private vs. Public
I disagree. Restaurants may be privately owned, but it's the public that they serve. If they truly want to be private in all respects, then they change their clientele and become a private or "closed" club, at which time the club members can vote among themselves whether to allow harmful activities to take place, such as smoking.
The majority of the public has apparently spoken - no smoking in restaurants.
The ignorance is astounding
Mr. Barret, your shrill rant as to the affiliation of Kerri's political stance is humorous. Equating Libertarianism with Right Wing politicos is, frankly, ignorant. I won't bother to explain, as a man of your knowledge surely knows how to use a dictionary (and I suggest you do so). However, you [as many of the anti-liberty crowd] still have a difficult coming to terms as to what public and private are. Restaurants are privately owned, get it, PRIVATE? Sorry if any of this offends you as we Libertarians tend to speak our minds, much like our forefathers did to Great Britain.
For government to tell an owner what he can and cannot do is a slice on liberty. Now many say it's not that big a deal. Ever hear of death of a thousand cuts?
Shill for the extreme right
Actually, Kerry is not a shill for the republican party; no, she is a shill for the far right, libertarian extreme side of the republican party. Those moderate and conservative, business oriented republicans are as much the enemy to her as are those darn democrats. Most of us support Governor Kaine in his public health oriented approach to smoking in public spaces. Now that we have finally broken the tyranny of silence that characterized the companies that promoted cigarette smoking, and now know of the billions of dollars that are spent on curing the health effects or burying the dead who died from smoking related illnesses, we as a community of citizens want to protect ourselves and others from these ill effects. But Kerry and her libertarian friends insist upon treating this as a freedom or liberty issue. Go out off the back porch and smoke all you want; just don't blow it on me.
I apologized too soon....
Orion, while the “majority” on that link are non-smoking, the statistics are skewed. To include places such as CNU Football Concession Stand, Costco Cafe, Denbigh Baptist Church Family Kitchen, Pizza Hut Delivery, Regal Cinema Theaters, and Sonic falsely inflates the numbers. Places like concession stands and Sonics only serve outdoors, so they don’t qualify as restaurants in the conventional sense. But to include such places as Pizza Hut Delivery and Papa Johns? C’mon – that’s simply ridiculous.
Sure, there are a few full-service places on the list (Red Lobster and Silver Diner), but they are certainly in the minority of full-service and are greatly outnumbered by fastfood (McD’s) and non-restaurant places (Starbucks, Target Stores). My post made on 2/12 stands.
I stand corrected
Orion correctly pointed out the error of my ways. Too bad the web link isn't more publicized - unless I've missed that as well. Good info there, Orion! Now I can be more selective on the places I patronize!
Smoking Ban
Nicotine is an addictive drug like coke, meth, etc. I guess your dislike of Democrats makes you support such a idiotic cause as allowing smoking in public places. Smoking related diseases are a very significant part of our out of control health care costs, not to mention the consequencies families have to face when a parent or spouse is hit with lung cancer or heart disease or some or serious medical problem caused by nicotine addiction. You seem to be a politcal shill for the republican party, not an honest and fair minded commentator. It would be good if the Pilot had a better quality of columnist than you. Your columns seem to lack depth, honesty and thoughtfulness. Maybe you should write a column on the Hitler movement in the catholic church.
re: Kerry wrong - again
RicM25798 wrote:
>>>Kerry, you state, and I quote, "most eateries are already smoke-free." Ok...do you patronize just one or two places? Most places I patronize are NOT smoke free, and they range from national chain "eateries" as well as the locally or family owned.
Sorry, but just because the few places you eat at may be smokefree does not entitle you to make a statement that's all-ecompassing, not to mention inaccurate.<<<
Wrong [again?] Ric! 68% of eateries in Virginia are smoke-free. I suggest a simple Google search before you use your "experiences" as proof.
http://www.healthspace.ca/vdh Click [under NEW]"Non-Smoking Restaurant Statistics"