79°
forecast

Federal stimulus dollars can't last forever

Posted to: Editorials Opinion

An America facing a full-scale economic collapse first has to avert it, by whatever means necessary. Shore up the banks. Keep people in their homes. Stimulate job creation by building roads and schools. Keep the auto companies afloat. Cut taxes.

This nation escaped the 20th century's Great Depression only after a huge amount of federal spending on a huge variety of enterprises, including World War II. The Depression still caused untold pain and suffering, but in 15 years, the nation had recovered.

Taking its cue from that, the Obama administration - and the Bush White House before it - has used an unthinkable amount of money to prop up an economy on the verge of collapse.

No one, honestly, has a full accounting of precisely how many dollars have been spent on banks and insurance companies, on mortgage companies and homeowners, on roads and schools and health insurance for the unemployed, on car companies and the railroads.

With a combination of expanded money supply, new debt and straight spending, Washington has extended more cash in a year than it has in most decades. The current federal deficit will be a figure we've never seen before and will be only a fractional estimate of how much skin Americans have in this fight.

All that is as it has to be. What doesn't have to be is the political mischief that has accompanied this crisis. From Democrats using spending to insinuate Washington ever deeper into the economy to Republicans who rediscovered fiscal conservatism only when the other party controlled the spending, Congress has borne out the nation's worst fears about it.

The government has committed $20,000 for each of us - man, woman and child - in service of the theory that massive spending can prevent massive pain. We've loaned money, but we've also given it away. The complete lack of accounting of where our trillions have gone - or even how much we've actually spent - is just one of the scary uncertainties we now face.

Last month, Democrats wielding pitchforks confiscated bonuses from executives at AIG while neglecting to find time to regulate its industry, where excesses created the fiscal crisis in the first place. When this page suggested that anger with AIG was a place to start, we didn't believe Congress would also stop there.

True to the political adage that a good crisis should never be wasted, Democrats have also spent the past 60 days busying themselves extending the reach of the federal government and reversing 30 years of deregulatory fervor. In the meantime, the GOP has gone into a positively Hooverian crouch, a party of the reflexive "no" to the Democrats' automatic "yes."

There has been good work done by both the Obama administration and its predecessor in identifying the depth of the trouble facing the nation and in throwing out enough lifelines. But huge sums have been spent. The accounting must begin.

All of which is to say that after months of throwing money hither and yon, spending not just our grandchildren's taxes but our great-grandchildren's taxes, the time has come to begin seriously considering how the nation will pay this giant bill.

COMMENTS ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here; comments do not reflect the views of The Virginian-Pilot or its websites. Users must follow agreed-upon rules: Be civil, be clean, be on topic; don't attack private individuals, other users or classes of people. Read the full rules here.
- Comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the report violation link below it.

Where's a media e can count on?

You can't spend or borrow your way out of debt, no matter who or what you are. Maybe if the Pilot and it's fellow media bretheren had been holding all politicians accountable, instead of abandoning all pretense of being society's watchdogs and throwing all their resources into advancing the Dem Party's agenda only, this whole crisis might have been avoided. If the Pilot's owners and Editorial Board memebers are going to be Democrats first, foremost, and ONLY, with no considerations about how being AMERICANS, or Virginians, or Tidewater residents, fits into any of this, then this column represents just more drivel that shouldn't be believed.

Have the editors at the

Have the editors at the pilot been in outer space since Obama took office? Start thinking about how we're going to pay back the stimulus money? Are you kidding me? Obama and the Congress have only just begun. Haven't you been paying attention? Spend, spend and spend some more. Us citizens can't spend. What we have left in our paychecks is eaten up by taxes,higher utilities, higher insurance and on and on it goes. That's what the pilot doesn't get. Retail sales declined in march, well, we don't have money to spend. Also, I read that there was a record decline in gas prices, that's certainly not reflected in the prices at the stations around here. It's up to $1.98 a gal. at some stations. Pay it back, we're indebted to the gov. and China for eternity and that's just how they want it. Wake up.

No checks or balances

To be honest, I don't agree with a lot that the Democrats and our President are doing with the economy right now. I guess that they are attempting to do something and the only thing they know how to do well is spend money. I do think that it would have been nice to have given some time for lawmakers and the concerned public to read the bill in full and been given time to digest all of it before making it law. I suspect that it will be months before it has all been disclosed of what is entirely on the bill. I would like to see some alternatives from the Republicans but I think right now they are pretty much neutered by the Democrats in congress and the President right now. There seems to be no true checks and balances in our government right now and that is a dangerous thing.

Relax folks...

The VP didn't lose its liberal compass. The statement "the time has come to begin seriously considering how the nation will pay this giant bill." is just their way of a preemptive argument for tax hikes.

Government spending

Good grief! Don’t you read history? The nation did not escape the Depression because of government spending but in spite of government spending. Tell me how the GOP saying no to the Democrats insane extension of the reach of federal government constitutes a “positively Hooverian crouch” and is a “reflexive ‘no’”? Is this the “fairness” act in practice? The Democrats do something and the GOP says no and one balances the other? Gimme a break! Although I agree totally with you that BOTH parties are (or have been) out of control, there is simply no reason to put the GOP in the same league as Obama and the Democrat-controlled Congress. Why don’t the loons who castigated Bush about spending so much money do the same to Obama?

Can you say TEA PARTY, AMERICA?

Sorry Dave... you’ve misunderstood The role of ‘Journalism’...

“... but this is a newspaper...you're supposed to print the truth. Or at least that's what I thought...”

Printing or otherwise illuminating the ‘unvarnished truth’ is no longer the mantra of journalistic enterprise. That Old-School fable was tossed out the window since the invention of the ‘Information Highway’ & the ‘New Media.’

Targeting the reading/listening/viewing audiences via demographic-orientation, personal-interest & opinion-orientation is now at the vanguard of how the New Media works.

Style of presentation & the perception of fulfilling the needs of a pre-defined niche-market, are far more important than the veracity of core-content.

In short The flogging of opinions is what causes the reading/listening /viewing audience to pay attention, not the reporting & recitation of simple facts.

The ‘Facts’ no longer matter... Peoples reactions to ‘Opinions’ do.

Huh?

many years of VP Op Ed praising every far left liberal program from tax hikes to welfare increases for all and now they tell us the stimulus money wont last? They just were ranting about the Republicans not accepting more unemployment compensation for part time workers and now they whine? Duh! Debt is debt and President Obama, Congressman Glenn Nye will pay for this massive debt in the next election cycle.

Laughable facts...are editors educated?

"This nation escaped the 20th century's Great Depression only after a huge amount of federal spending on a huge variety of enterprises"

You're kidding, right? There's study after study that proves that the Great Depression was made longer by several years because of this. While I agree it doesn't fit into the Democrats platform / agenda, but this is a newspaper...you're supposed to print the truth. Or at least that's what I thought.

That was the whole point!

After editorial after editorial castigating Republicans in the House of Delegates for halting spending programs funded by a stimulus package that will run out, the Pilot suddenly proclaims that the stimulus money won't last forever.

Perhaps when publishing these contradictory editorials, the Pilot can also print which side of the coin flip won - heads or tails.

Heads, oppose Republicans on permanently changing unemployment laws for temporary stimulus money, or tails, oppose temporary stimulus money.

What will the flip be tomorrow?

not surprising

the city of va beach wants to throw 10 million right in the ocean ,

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Please note: Threaded comments work best if you view the oldest comments first.

More articles from: Editorials rss feed    Opinion rss feed   


Toolbox