Hampton Roads, VA - 02/09/2010
Clear30°Clear
Forecasts | Doppler Radar
Traffic Cameras & VDOT Alerts

Teens organize on Web, plan sit-in over MacArthur rules

Posted to: News Norfolk

What they say
Teens organizing the protests and Facebook groups say they want to show mall managers how much they stand to lose. The policy set to take effect Oct. 19 requires those younger than 18 to have a chaperone.

Facebook groups
• Boycott the Macarthur Center
• Protest MacArthur Mall Age Restriction!
• Petition/Boycott MacArthur mall

NORFOLK

MacArthur Center's plan to implement new restrictions on teenagers at the downtown mall has prompted a groundswell of protest from young shoppers, their parents and others.

At least a half-dozen Facebook groups have popped up on the social networking Web site since Monday under such titles as "MacArthur is not being fair!" and "Boycott MacArthur Mall Teen-Chaperone Policy." One of the groups has scheduled a sit-in at 5 p.m. Oct. 18 - 24 hours before the new mall policy takes effect.

MacArthur Center officials announced Monday that the mall would start requiring shoppers younger than 18 to have a "supervising adult" 21 or older with them if they come to the mall after 5 p.m. It's the first mall in the region to implement such a policy.

Quint Guvernator and the 940 or so members of his Facebook group "MacArthur is not being fair!" aren't happy about the change. Quint, a 14-year-old who attends Norfolk Academy, started the group and is organizing the sit-in to stop MacArthur Center from going forward with the policy - or at least reconsider it, he said.

As of Wednesday evening, 100 "confirmed guests" had signed up for the event.

"They're going to lose a lot of money," Quint said. "We lose a place to hang out. We lose the ability to watch movies with friends."

A government teacher at Norfolk Collegiate School encouraged her class to discuss the issue Tuesday, said Alanna Miller, a 17-year-old senior in the class. She and fellow classmates formed the Facebook group "Protest MacArthur Mall Age Restriction!" and scheduled a meeting during their school lunch break Wednesday to find other interested students.

About 15 to 20 teens came to the meeting, Alanna said. They agreed to start a petition and get as many signatures as possible.

"At 17, you're allowed to go to an R-rated movie by yourself," Alanna said. "We're definitely hoping that they'll change" the policy.

Jim Wofford, the mall's general manager, did not return a call Wednesday.

The teens behind the protest groups recognize their value as consumers. Teenage Research Unlimited, a Chicago market research company that specializes in young consumers, estimates that shoppers ages 12 to 19 will spend $85 billion in 2009.

"By doing this, they are preventing teenagers who are more than willing to support the mall by purchasing merchandise, food and movie tickets, from using the mall when it's most convenient," reads the mission statement of the "Boycott the MacArthur Center" group on Facebook. "If MacArthur wants to cut down on its customer base, we will help them."

Quint and Alanna said they cannot easily adhere to the new policy. Asking their parents or another adult to accompany them after 5 p.m. is impractical, they said.

"It's going to be hard for my parents to come with me," said Alanna, explaining that they have other things to do. "And I can drive. If I can drive myself to the mall, why do I need someone to come with me?"

Shopping within the hours that don't require a chaperone also is difficult, they said.

Sports and other activities often keep them busy as late as 6 p.m. on weekdays, and they tend to go to the movies after dark on weekends.

So, once the new policy starts, they plan to shop elsewhere.

"A lot of my friends are going to Lynnhaven Mall," Alanna said.

Quint, who spends much of his time at MacArthur Center in the Apple store, said he and his friends could frequent the Apple kiosk within Best Buy stores instead. "We'll just find another way to do it."

Carolyn Shapiro, (757) 446-2270, carolyn.shapiro@pilotonline.com



ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Comments do not reflect the views of The Virginian-Pilot or its Web sites. Comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Report Violation" link below the comment.

Bravo McArthur!!

I have worked at malls for years before, and have been a teenager in a mall before. Teenagers are loud, unruley and scare away customers that really do want to purchase something. The only thing they want to do at the mall is socialize, boy shop, and loiter. I think their business will actually grow due to this. I will actually go out of my way to shop here now.

Personally, I cant wait till all these teenagers get arrested at the sit-in.

In addition, have they thought that

a nineteen-year old mother of a 6 month old child now has to get a sitter? Technically, that would be a violation. McArthur will now have to define the lower end of the child spectrum. A six month old baby has to be with someone over 21. If they don't enforce the exact provisions of the law, it will lead to case by case enforcement, and inevitably discrimination cases.

Rovin has a point. Let's test it.

Let's have an adult take some kids to the mall and see what constitutes being with the kids. In the store next to them? within eyesight? within hearing distance? twenty feet away? thirty feet away? thirty-one feet away? In the food court while they watch a movie? In the food court while they drink coffee at barnes and nobles? In the second floor of B&N while they are in the first floor? Can the parent drop them off then go park? Let's test this and see what McArthur Center does? They will have to exactly define what counts as chaperoning.

If teens [or anyone] wants

If teens [or anyone] wants to protest, they should buy an airline ticket and buy their goodies from the source.....China!

All malls should follow

I can't stand going to the mall because of all teenagers. Hopefully Lynnhaven and Greenbrier will follow. Maybe now we can get some higher end department stores.

Facebook group "Protest MacArthur Mall Age Restriction!"

I'm still in favor of the ban, but I do think the organizers of the Facebook group "Protest MacArthur Mall Age Restriction!" deserve credit for their efforts. They articulated their cause calmly and succinctly, backing it up with research. Their reason for no longer supporting a sit-in demonstrates a lot of maturity. Nice job!

Case By Case

Since there are teens who ARE mature, shopping, spending, going to the movies on a date and etc, why can't they just put up a policy against too many grouped together, or, perhaps under 16, where you don't drive. I'd say let the mall suffer for the loss of those who are responsible. I personally don't shop that mall anymore because the only store I went for, closed. SO.....I really don't care. Just looking from my own life experiences. I am a leftover from the 70's if you will!

Give it a chance to work before shooting it down.

I have lived in other cities with similar policies. I guess people are under the impression that there will be Bouncers at the Mall doors checking ID's. This is not the case; if you are a teenager in the Mall Shopping and acting like you have some sense and home training then you would be able to come and go as you please. However, if you are being disorderly, Security would immediately request to speak to the adult chaperone. If there is no one to take responsibility for the person or group, Security will be allowed to immediately escort the disorderly person or group out the Mall and off the property. It actually gives the Mall more leeway in policing bad behavior instead of filling out reports and calling police only to have the culprits walk off only to return later causing more problems I personally; go to the mall with my children or rotate as a chaperone between the parents of their friends. I have personally seen Malls go from Trashy to Classy once the word is out that nonsense will not be tolerated. I think it will work

Location, Location, Location

You can't build a mall in the middle of a major city and not expect kids to hang out. The problem is not kids under 18 years of age, it is groups of kids under 18 years of age. If the mall was to ban the groups, than the ACLU and Jesse Jackson would be attending the protest. However, by stating that anyone under the age of 18 cannot go to the mall without a parent is an out and poor judgement. Why 5pm, why not 4pm, or 3pm or why not at all times? Chesapeake Square ran out the kids about 10 years ago and they were quick to realize that they had a tremendous loss of revenue. Now they have the elderly running track through an empty mall and drinking coffee at McDonalds all afternoon. However, we can complain about their actions, but what about solutions. I believe that the kids need to behave and any kid not behaving should be asked to leave. Take the kids name and after being removed three times, charge the kid for disturbing the peace and place a restraining order on the youth. Don't make properly raised kids suffer for the actions of those who don't have any manners. And, don't build malls in the middle of large cities and neighborhoods.

LOCATION:

GREAT IDEA, Three shots,and if you can't behave yourself properly, OUT THE DOOR YOU GO. No if,ands,or buts about it. If you want to be loud and noisy,and act like a jerk,outside has PLENTY OF SPACE ,WAY TO GO MacARTHUR...

Malls are for $hopping...Not "hanging out"....(i.e. Loitering)

Note to Teeagers: Malls are for $hopping...NOT for "hanging out" (i.e. Loitering). Here's what bothers me, "We lose a place to hang out. We lose the ability to watch movies with friends." Go to FRIENDS houses. Problem is when unproductive teenagers "hang out" they cause trouble and do STUPID behavior and then start fights. Parents: Keep an EYE on your teenagers and MALLS are not for hanging out. Be a parent and keep your children at home doing productive stuff (i.e., studying). If they're under 21, they need to be SUPERVISED by an adult. I'm sure teenagers won't affect the mall's economic issues. Teenagers don't have stable jobs TO spend money in the malls...in that case...they can't go to malls unless they have mommy and daddy's money. GET A JOB. It's that simple. Business owners don't like "hang outs" and non productivity. Hang out elsewhere...not the mall.

I would be more inclined to go to MacArthur now

I don't go to malls to shop around. If I go, I go to the store I need to go to and go in/out the store itself (i.e., Sears, Pennys, etc). Try going to Greenbrier Mall (to name just one) - you can barely get through the groups hanging out.....I would be more inclined to go shopping in the other stores in the mall if I didn't have to go around these groups. Exactly how much money are they spending anyway? Are they buying stuff every single day? NO...they are just hanging out. Parents, become real parents and find something else for your teens to do other than hang around. Have them over to your house.

Of course it's not just

Of course it's not just because they are kids. There are many reasons. I mean, have you looked at some of these crowds? I go to this mall. I see them. But I am not them - I am a responsible, self-employed man - one who lives downtown and is able to spend a lot of money at MacArthur Center. But I will purposely avoid stores when I see derelict punks hanging around inside, outside, or in the general vicinity. Any store catering to that crowd is not catering to me. I don't tolerate that kind of company. So let the mall decide; which kind of clientele do you seek? Your call. Whatever you do, please ignore the ridiculous, politically correct excuses.

Just to add...

This new mall policy is a bad idea, especially in this economy when stores are trying to keep their profits up. I think stores like Forever 21, Hot Topic, Vans, and others that cater to customers under 18 and up, will see a significant drop in sales. What about the few adults who act inappropriately? Will they be punished? So, are these teenagers being punished simply on the basis of their age? This just doesn't sit well with me. I think there's some other motivation behind it.

I wonder...

Does the "supervising adult" have to stay with these young people? How close exactly is 'with' defined? I took a small group of 14 year old girls to MacArthur for an afternoon of shopping and movie recently. I was in the mall doing my shopping (not keen on shopping at the same stores, really) but I didn't follow them around. They kept in contact by cell so I knew where they were but I suppose they could have been up to random acts of vandalizing shops or moving Pottery Barn pillows and terrorizing people that are afraid of kids because of their funny hair or clothes or sinister piercings. Or kids that laugh too loud or talk too loud or carry skateboards or have baggy clothes. I have been going to 'the mall' since the mall was invented and I find many of the adults ‘way scarier’ than the kids.
Next time we’ll go where freedom rings and cash registers too.

How come noone answers the comments made about underage milita

I find it funny that the one comment that nevers gets an answer, is the one about the underage serviceman and women (ages 17, 18 & 19 year olds). I bring this up because i graduated highschool at 17, joined the navy at 17 went to bootcamp and was in "A" school at 18 at Damn Neck then stationed in Cuba at 19. Do these men and women now have to find a 21 year old friend to go to the mall or are they not allowed to get some privacy and alone time to go shopping.

I do have a problem with the having to be insight of the adult at all times. what happens at Xmas when you have teenagers that want to surprisetheir parents with gifts. I do allow my son who is 14 that little bit of freedom every year where i give him money and sit at the middle of the mall in the seats and let him go shopping for me and my husband so that he can have that little bit of control and be able to surprise us with something he chose himself. He is able to see me and comes straight to me when his shopping is done and if not he checks in to say he is still looking.

I grew up in an the age of the 80's early 90's, where we went to the malls on Fri & Sat nights after school, working or sports to go the arcades, g

Here's an answer

I'll go out on a limb and answer your question. The 17yo military person will be welcomed at the mall. After all, if they misbehave the shore patrol station is only a couple of blocks away. The wonders of that little ID card.

Easy remedy

The mall should file a suit tortious interference with business against anyone that prevents commerce to the mall. Most people won't complain if they have to pay to do so.

Parents, don't worry your children are responsible for their own torts.

Senseless

I think a lot of you folks are misunderstanding exactly what ages are being banned here. They are not just talking about preteens, whom I do agree should not be 'dropped off' without proper parental oversight. We are talking about people who are NOT of an age to NEED babysitters, people who are of an age where they can legally own and operate a vehicle, people who are old enough to have jobs and be tax paying citizens and (unfortunately) consumers. Many of you assume these kids are using their parents money, it's not your business, but even if they are: did your parents/grandparents NEVER give you money for allowance, side jobs, good grades, holiday shopping etc?
Everyone needs to stop punishing all kids because most of you are afraid of a handful of them. Sure MacMall needs to do something about the troublemakers, but not at the expense of all the rest. When I was a 16 yr old employed student if I had been banned from the mall that I drove to and paid parking fee to and spent MY money in, I would have boycotted it.

kids in the Mall

Why dont they permit the underage thugs...children to just occupy the upstairs floor with the food and theater? Or make it where two can hang but not more than that?.This is a prime example of a shotgun approach rather than a pistol. Get the ones who are casuing problems not the masses.
Maybe issue ID cards like public recreation deparments.Scan cards as they pass?? I dont know.

I am sick of taking my family to Mac mall and getting checked out from every punk who wants to eyeball a pretty bunch of girls.I love the Mac Arthur Mall, fact is, its the best one in our area right now. Greenbriar is geting worse by the week, Lynnhaven is flat out scary and Military has been gone for a long time. Mac Mall is the last survivor. I guess we could go to Shortpump???

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Please note: Threaded comments work best if you view the oldest comments first.

More News Stories

More articles from: News rss feed   


Toolbox