Sea-level rise slowly becomes issue in Outer Banks

Posted to: Environment News North Carolina

Coastal scientists are predicting that rising seas could drown much of the Outer Banks by the next century, but the issue is just starting to be recognized as a looming crisis in league with beach erosion.

Despite the vulnerability of the barrier islands to potentially catastrophic rising seas, there is no clarion call to be proactive.

"I think most people who spend time around the ocean probably think there is some rise in the ocean levels," said Allen Burrus, v ice c hairman of the Dare County Board of Commissioners and a Hatteras native. "But they also feel that, like most things in nature, it comes in cycles."

A science panel - hosted by the state Department of Environment and Natural Resources - this month presented data that showed seas off the Outer Banks have risen 0.17 of an inch a year over a 24-year period, the highest rate in the state. Data will be reviewed every five years to observe trends.

Tancred Miller, policy analyst for the state Division of Coastal Management, said a report based on the panel's analysis soon will be presented to the state Coastal Resources Commission, which will use it to begin drafting policies on rising sea levels. Eventually, he said, local governments in the state's 20 coastal counties will be expected to incorporate the policies into their land-use plans.

For the time being, the town of Nags Head is addressing severe beach erosion and storm damage on the oceanfront on the south end of the town, but the topic of rising sea levels is not on the table.

"There's not been a discussion, really," Town Manager Cliff Ogburn said. "We've been talking about beach erosion for a very long time. Does sea-level rise contribute to it? Probably. To me beach erosion is not a new topic - sea-level rise is."

Ogburn said the town is seeking permits and funds for a beach nourishment project. Meanwhile, it is working to get damaged houses off the beach, he said.

Future plans, he said, will probably include increasing setbacks for oceanfront houses.

The science panel projected that if the same rate is maintained, sea levels would rise 1.3 feet this century.

If they rise at the expected global rate - based on measurements from global tide gauges and satellites - then seas on the North Carolina coast would rise 3.3 feet, which would inundate much of the low-lying barrier islands. If ocean levels rise at the accelerated rate some scientists project, sea levels could increase as much as 4.6 feet here.

"You're already seeing it," said science panel member Stanley Riggs, a coastal geology research professor at East Carolina University. "It's been going on for decades. It's the storms that cause the erosion. If we didn't have a rising sea level, we'd have a nice happy beach."

Riggs said that as the levels rise, erosion will increase, and more houses will be claimed by the ocean. The only way to address the inevitable is to retreat.

"It's crazy for anyone to think they can build a house on that shoreline with a rising sea level," he said. "For the long term - which is longer than a mayor's elected for - if you're going to manage these beaches and keep them viable, then you've got to get those houses out of the way. You've got to get the road out of the way.

"North Carolina has to start thinking long term," Riggs said, "or we're going to lose our tourism industry."

But Burrus, the Dare commissioner, said he is more prone to listen to islanders who have observed the beach come and go, who have lived through a decade in the 1960s with no hurricanes and who remember when the sound used to freeze every winter.

"I guarantee you, there are lots of answers - we just have to figure it out," he said. "Most of those people have degrees, but they don't have any practical knowledge. Science is science, but it changes all the time."

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Catherine Kozak, (252) 441-1711, cate.kozak@pilotonline.com

COMMENTS ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here; comments do not reflect the views of The Virginian-Pilot or its websites. Users must follow agreed-upon rules: Be civil, be clean, be on topic; don't attack private individuals, other users or classes of people. Read the full rules here.
- Comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the report violation link below it.

The feelings are just wishful thinking

"I think most people who spend time around the ocean probably think there is some rise in the ocean levels," said Allen Burrus, vice chairman of the Dare County Board of Commissioners and a Hatteras native. "But they also feel that, like most things in nature, it comes in cycles."

Take a look at the 80 year long tide record up at Sewell's Point, VA, ( http://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/sltrends_station.shtml?stnid=8638610%20Sewells%20Point,%20VA ) and show me the "cycles". It has been a relentless 0.17"/year rise over the last 80 years. Averaging out the noise from the cycles and looking at the trend line, there's 8"+ more water for storms to work now with than in the Burruss' golden age of the storm-free 60s, or more than a foot since we started measuring. If there's some cycle that the local wisdom folks are counting on, its effect is small compared to the long term sea level rise.

If the thoughts and feelings of the natives are anything more than wishful thinking, they'll have to come up with something with a little more science than that sort of biorhythms-of-Gaia fantasy about cycles.

Stan Riggs has chosen to

Stan Riggs has chosen to tether his horse to the global warming/sea level rise bunch, and therefore has lost all credibility in search of the quick buck. Academia is lining up behined him, since they have no marketable skills, only loud, unfounded opinions hoping to cash in on the political winds.

So Sayeth Chicken Little.....

The Sky is Falling! ! ! The Sky is Falling! ! ! Everybody FREAK OUT! ! ! !

Math

Ya'll funny!

I for one

based on the scientific evidence, am unsure of what the climate is doing. But then, when the effects of global warming, if they happen, start ravaging the world I'll probably be dead and it won't matter to me. I have no children or grandchildren and have no stake in the future except for mine so I really don't care. I come to this after many years of watching those on the left and especially the right not caring either, about human rights, religious freedom, or individual freedom.

For the naysayers and supporters, have you read the scientific evidence of both sides? Until then how can you comment? ANd evidence interpreted by the Limbaughs and Olbermans of this world isn't science, it's opinion.

We, as a nation, have lost the ability to look at the evidence outside of partisan politics.

regretfully

Your last sentence is, to a very large extent, true.

essentially unsolveable problem

Even if everything the alarmists say about rising temperatures were true - and I certainly have my doubts - there isn't anything practical we can do about it. For one thing, the most extreme of them claim that if we essentially don't completely end our use of fossil fuels immediately it will be too late. Well, since most people get their electricity from fossil fuels and basically everyone's automobile runs on it, that, in short, aint' gonna happen. For another, China, India, Russia, Mexico and others have said they are not interested in and will not comply with any mandated reductions in green house gases, so even if the US were to enact cap-and-trade or even a more onerous regime, it wouldn't be a drop in the green house gas bucket, but would cost Americans an awful lot of money. IF everyone around the globe participated and IF it were proven it would make a differnce, I might be able to support it. Until that time, however (which I don't see in my lifetime), not so much.

The climate change part of the article is relatively small.

Most of the article is about the observed sea level rise without the climate change models. If the scientists are right about climate change, the article says it will only speed up the loss of beach due to sea level rise from 3.3ft/century to 4.4ft/century. As for actions, the article is talking about the very reasonable idea that planning and zoning in the outer banks should consider a foot or three of sea level rise over the lifetime of projects being planned.

Should anyone sign up for (or insure) a 30 year mortgage on low-lying areas outer banks if we're going to get an extra foot of water for future storms to slosh around? A house that came within an inch of flooding during Isabel would have that extra inch just 6 years later, and would get a full foot more in 22 to 70 years, according to the numbers in the article.

Let's see how much money we can scare people out of.

Global warming is now on the fast track of going the same way as the "global cooling" fear of the seventies and all the other global climate change scares since the beginning of record keeping. It seems there is no steady income for climate scientist other than to live off the federal government. If there is no climate crises for many years, the funding for these scientist dries up and they must go out and actually get a meaningful research job with finite outcome. These wild claims that are backed by false data and lack solid evidence are costing us billions. Anyone that has lived on the coast for anytime, know that the coastline is shifting sand. Anyone that has study our worlds climate at all, know that we have normal variations in temperature, winds, ice and water levels. I learned my lesson from the "global cooling", I actually believed it until the data to prove otherwise came out. Of course even then there was the claim that the warming trend we were having was part of the "global cooling" event. By then, we spent trillions of dollars on changing hair sprays, deodorants and millions of other products. Al Gore and Michael Moore should be tarred and feathered.

warming

OK so we have a group saying the earth is warming and it is going to cause the sea to rise!. If the earth is getting warmer is it not also going to cause more evaporation of the sea water???? I agree with the poster that says there are certain people trying to justify there jobs with this, How much did you hear about it before Doomsday Gore had to get a job?? People on the OB have been moving houses back for years and there are still houses here. The problem is the sand is not moving westward like it did naturaly and creating more island.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Please note: Threaded comments work best if you view the oldest comments first.

More articles from: Environment rss feed    News rss feed   


Toolbox


special features