GOP plan emerges to fix Va. shortfall

Posted to: News State Government Virginia

House of Delegates budget negotiators hope to overcome a multibillion-dollar budget shortfall in part by deeper cuts at state agencies, bigger contributions from state workers to their pension plans and more federal money to pay for Medicaid.

Each of those items are landmarks on a "road map" the Republican-controlled House is using to produce a budget by Feb. 21, the day both chambers are scheduled to release their spending plans.

The House spending plan, and the Senate's counterpart, have to compensate for a $4.2 billion shortfall. Former Gov. Timothy M. Kaine's outgoing budget contains more than half of those cuts, but legislators still need to find another $1.9 billion. Kaine proposed finding the money by eliminating the state's car tax relief subsidy to localities, but Republicans have dismissed that idea.

Senate Democrats continued Monday to tee off on Gov. Bob McDonnell for what they characterized as his delay in releasing budget amendments illustrating where he wants to cut.

And McDonnell announced that he plans to continue a school funding formula that will give Northern Virginia schools $128 million more in state aid but cost South Hampton Roads localities.

The House budget plan is based in part on a bill from Del. Lacey Putney, chairman of the House Appropriations Committee. It would require new government workers to contribute more toward their pension benefits, roll back cost-of-living adjustments and alter how a worker's age and years of service count toward retirement.

While it's envisioned as more of a long-range strategy,

one estimate suggests it could free up as much as $200 million to $300 million in the near term.

Officials also are anticipating approval of billions more in federal dollars to help states cover a share of Medicaid dollars until 2011. Those funds are part of the budget proposal President Barack Obama unveiled recently. That will free up state dollars that otherwise might have been used on health care costs.

Also being considered are proposals crafted by state department heads at the instruction of Kaine to show how agencies would function with graduated funding cuts up to 15 percent.

Deep cuts to education, public safety and health care were part of the Kaine

plan. And tough choices about deeper cuts are on the horizon.

"We haven't had it as bad as we have it with a hole this big in the budget from one governor to the next," said Appropriations Committee staff director Robert Vaughn, who nevertheless said the House is far enough along that it could produce a balanced budget by the end of this week if it had to.

A plan to offset the $1.9 billion with hundreds of millions in cuts to education and health and human services leaked from the Senate last week. But Senate officials said that is only one "scenario" that might not reflect their final proposal.

In that chamber Monday, Sen. Janet Howell said McDonnell's opposition to new revenues and his insistence that car tax relief continue "has boxed us in so that the only choice is cutting vital state services."

"The people of Virginia deserve to know how he will live up to his election promises," added Howell, a Fairfax County Democrat. "They deserve to know which state programs he wants us to cut. It is time, it is past time, for the governor to do the job he asked voters to elect him to do."

That rhetoric, Putney said, is motivated by Democrats' concerns that McDonnell hasn't presented his budget ideas "for them to throw rocks at and complain about on the floor."

"The way the governor is going about this deliberately and slowly working with both sides, both houses, I think it makes sense to approach the budget and the shortfall in that fashion," added Putney, a Bedford County independent who caucuses with the GOP.

McDonnell has rolled out some budget proposals in methodical fashion, but most have been new spending initiatives to fund his economic growth agenda.

Monday, he proposed another $29 million in spending to continue a state education funding formula that determines what share state and local government pay based on a wealth calculation. Last fall, school officials estimated that the formula would cost Virginia Beach

$15.5 million, Chesapeake $9.5 million, Norfolk $7.2 million and Suffolk and Portsmouth $4 million each.

Earlier in the day, Hampton Democratic Sen. Mamie Locke and education advocates lobbied for passage of legislation that would pump money into education with a menu of new levies, including collections of certain corporate, estate and income taxes. McDonnell has said he will not support any tax increases.

Julian Walker, (804) 697-1564, julian.walker@pilotonline.com

COMMENTS ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here; comments do not reflect the views of The Virginian-Pilot or its websites. Users must follow agreed-upon rules: Be civil, be clean, be on topic; don't attack private individuals, other users or classes of people. Read the full rules here.
- Comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the report violation link below it.

Budget issues

Virginia runs a fairly tight ship. Just like any other big entity it has its problems and waste, but generally we do a good job of spending money. The state paying for part of the car tax was a stupid idea to begin with. It makes no sense on any level. Get rid of the car tax reimbursement, freeze state spending, and raise the maximum state income tax a small amount above the current 5.75%. Everyone who makes above 30k in Virginia only pays 5.75%. Move that up in very small increments up to a maximum of say 7% for those who make large incomes. Putting tolls on roads to pay for improvements on that road and its replacement make sense. If you use the road then you pay. If you don't use the road then you don't directly pay.

Time to show some compassion

So long as we just keep discussing numbers, no one really knows the flesh and blood employees and their families who will be put out of work by the fiscal policies of this administration. Sure, they have a mandate; no new taxes, but no one really knew the effect of that in terms of economic disruption to Virginia cities and towns, When tens of thousands of workers lose their jobs, not only will services be cut, but so will businesses that depend upon those with these incomes, be disrupted as well. So McDonnell is the jobs Governor? Yeah, the loss of jobs Governor. Regretfully, those democrats and moderates who helped give him landslide are about to find out what limited Government really means. The poor, the sick, the disabled, the young, the families of those fired, will be the first effected, but the ripple effects will be great as well. Time to think about an increase in the income tax.

Well, all of those workers

Well, all of those workers who get pink slips, please apply at Runnymeade Corporation and Mike Barrett will definitely hire you for a job. If you are so un-happy here Mike, why do you stay? It seems to me you would be much happier in NJ or NY where they tax about 80% of your income and you have to have two jobs to afford a one bedroom apartment. Maybe you would feel more at home stroking a tax check every few days to some local entity of government. You obviously find comfort in paying something like 65 cents a gallon in gas taxes and like NY where tolls bridges and tunnels from Manhatten to Brooklyn are in the neighborhood of $12.00 each way. That sounds more like your life style. Virginians can do more with less.

Right

"Virginians can do more with less."
Yeah. And MickyDee is going to provide us with less!

He'll sure do alot better

He'll sure do alot better than Kandy Kaine.

but if we charge for paper or plastic bags

We come up with $47.9m in revenue the first year!

Revenue vs. Cuts

Kaine at least offered a budget that did not rely on one-time federal revenue. McDonnell is merely avoiding critical decisions by using non-recurring money from the federal government. Apparently he is not bothered by the fact that he is/was a vocal critic of ARRA. So by refusing to eliminate the car tax subsidy, he must cut almost $2 billion in state programs. This will hurt the citizens, in particular children in K-12.
By the way, debt and deficit are related. The bulk of the national deficit was caused by the Bush administration borrowing (debt) money to pay for two wars, offset lost revenue due to tax cuts and the unfunded Medicare prescription plan. Measuring the deficit (caused by borrowing)as a percentage of GDP however is a valid gauge of the relative size of the deficit.

As reliable as clockwork...

It's Bushes fault again?!? Did you know he's the reason we have Global warming? And this record snow fall, yep you guessed it. Bush has a secret weather machine that changes the weather. And, he fixes gas prices too... Are you kidding me? Please join me in a small reality
break.

News flash...it's corrupt politicians fault. Both parties using your money to buy influance and fund pet projects. It needs to stop from both parties and at all levels of government. I commend the Govenor for attempting to correct the many years long problem. However, I see doom, gloom and more of the same old stuff in the future. I hope I'm wrong, but, alas, I doubt it.
We now return you to your dilusional bashing of whatever party you choose...
Just a thought.

VA Shortfall?

Maybe this shortfall could be corrected by having all individuals over the age of 21, who live and/or work in the state of Virginia, paying their taxes. It shouldn't matter what their annual income is, everyone should pay and they don't. Any single individual who makes $11,250 or less, married $22,500, do not have to pay a dime in state taxes. With that being the case shouldn't everyone get their first $11,250/$22,500 tax free? No thats not how it works.Those who earn more than that have to pay taxes on every dime. And its up to that group to make up all the tax dollars the state needs. Instead of raising taxes they need to be having everyone pay their share.

But wait, There's more!

Governor Bobby McDee has promised us that we will receive windfall moneys from offshore drilling! And we ALL know that he would never lie,

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Please note: Threaded comments work best if you view the oldest comments first.

More articles from: News rss feed    State Government rss feed   


Toolbox


Partners

special features