First-term Democrat Nye voting against health care bill
Posted to: Health Care Reform News
U.S. Rep. Glenn Nye announced Saturday night he is voting against the Democratic health care bill today, saying it doesn't do enough to reduce the cost of health care, would make deep cuts in some hospital funding, and could cause problems for Tricare recipients.
"Over the past year, I have spoken with countless small business owners, families, medical professionals, and average citizens across Virginia's 2nd District, and it became very clear that this bill was not the right solution for Virginia's health care challenges," Nye said in a written statement. "There were many strong points in this bill that I would have been happy to support individually, but the package as a whole had serious problems."
The Virginia Beach Democrat has been the focus of a high-pressure campaign by supporters and opponents of legislation that is headed for a showdown vote in the U.S. House today.
"I know there are some people who will be disappointed with my vote," Nye said, "but I believe that I have a firm duty to vote my conscience and represent the best interests of my district."
While Nye - whose district includes Virginia Beach, parts of Norfolk and Hampton, and the Eastern Shore - had held off making his intentions known until the eve of the vote, his decision is consistent with his "no" vote on a similar health care overhaul bill that passed the House in November.
Nye said he objects to the bill's proposal to cut supplemental Medicaid payments to children's hospitals, including Children's Hospital of The King's Daughters in Norfolk. Nye said those hospitals could lose $16 billion under the bill.
"This bill did not fix the key flaws with the original health care bill... and I am not convinced it will effectively reduce the cost of health care for families and small businesses," he said.
There is also concern that participants in the military's Tricare health plan may be subject to some health care provisions, under the latest version of the bill. Under previous versions, Tricare patients were exempt.
"I am not willing to risk negative consequences for our military personnel and their families, particularly at a time when our troops are serving overseas in harm's way," Nye said.
Other representatives from Hampton Roads already have announced how they will vote.
U.S. Rep. Bobby Scott, a Newport News Democrat, supports the legislation. U.S. Reps. Randy Forbes of Chesapeake and Rob Wittman of Westmoreland County - both Republicans - intend to vote against it.
Meanwhile, with Democrats increasingly confident they have enough support, the House of Representatives planned Saturday for a historic vote today that would enact the most dramatic changes in the nation's health care system in decades.
As a sign of that confidence - and to quiet concerns among Democrats as well as Republicans - House leaders abandoned a plan to approve the Senate's health care legislation without a direct vote.
President Barack Obama, in a politically charged visit to Capitol Hill, tried to rally support for the measure by telling the House's 253 Democrats to ignore the gloom-and-doom midterm election scenarios that Republican leaders and pundits have suggested if they pass the health care measure.
"You're here to represent your constituencies, and if you think your
constituencies honestly shouldn't be helped, you shouldn't vote for this," Obama said. "But if you agree the system's not working for ordinary families... then help us fix this system."
"Don't do it for me. Don't do it for the Democratic Party," he said. "Do it for the American people."
Before Obama's arrival on Capitol Hill, House leaders worked feverishly to round up the last undecided votes to reach the 216 needed for passage.
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., was confident about today's prospects, saying flatly, "We will pass the bill."
The pace was furious and sometimes heated both inside and outside the Capitol, where tea party demonstrators gathered to protest the bill.
Inside the building, House Democratic leaders dropped a controversial plan that would have "deemed" Senate-approved health care legislation passed as part of a resolution setting rules of debate but would not have required House members to vote directly on the legislation.
House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer, D-Md., said Democrats abandoned "deem and pass" because the party leadership is confident it can get the votes to pass the health care bill.
"We determined that we could do this, and it's a better process," Hoyer said. "We believe we have the votes."
The maneuver had been seen as a way to allow Democrats to avoid voting on the bill, but Democrats were uneasy about the prospect. Rep. William Lacy Clay, D-Mo., said it looked like a "back-door deal."
"We've had sanity prevail here," said Rep. Dennis Cordoza, D-Calif., a supporter of the legislation. "This is something that should be done in the light of day."
Hoyer said the House would vote first today on a bill that would change parts of the health care bill the Senate passed on Dec. 24. Then, if that bill passes, the House will vote on the Senate health care bill.
The second vote would send the Senate bill to Obama to sign while the first bill would go to the Senate for a vote under so-called "reconciliation" rules that prohibit a filibuster and would require only 51 votes for passage. The Democrats control 59 Senate seats.
Pelosi and others continued to meet with a handful of anti-abortion Democrats who had refused to support the bill. Several alternatives were proposed, including an executive order reiterating that federal policy toward abortion would not change, or a separate vote to toughen abortion restrictions.
A separate vote on abortion language will not happen today, Rep. Diana DeGette, D-Colo., a leader of the abortion rights forces, said.
Meanwhile, House Democratic leaders hope to attract more nervous Democrats by showing them a letter from Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., and signed by more than 50 Democratic senators that says they'll support the reconciliation bill.
The legislation would require most employers and consumers to obtain coverage by 2014 or face penalties. Families earning up to $88,000 a year would be eligible for help paying premiums. Consumers would be able to use new exchanges, or marketplaces, to easily shop for coverage.
The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimates the plan would reduce the federal deficit by $138 billion over 10 years. It includes a series of tax increases, including higher Medicare payroll taxes on the wealthy and a new tax on dividend, interest and other unearned income.
McClatchy Newspapers contributed to this report.
COMMENTS ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here; comments do not reflect the views of The Virginian-Pilot or its websites. Users must follow agreed-upon rules: Be civil, be clean, be on topic; don't attack private individuals, other users or entire classes of people. Read the full rules here.
- Comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the report violation link below it.
More News Stories
More articles from:
News




Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Facebook
Google
Yahoo

Health Care Reform
As a long-time resident of Virginia, and I am writing to thank Rep. Nye for his recent “No” vote on the subject of Health Care Reform. I wanted to express my full support for Rep. Nye and his decision to support his constituents wishes as well as looking after Virginia’s best interests. I firmly believe that this bill’s passage was not written with President Obama’s campaign promise of transparency in mind.
I understand that some in our community do support this bill, without realizing how it will affect the majority of citizens in our community. I commend Rep. Nye with standing up for what he believes is right, despite the pressure of the media, local and national.
DEMOCRATS UNITE AGAINST NYE
Mr Nye is a total fraud. He is a lifelong Republican who was never registered as a democrat. He didn't vote for 2 years prior to running for congress. Nye ran as a democrat only because he knew he could win on the coattails of Obama/Warner. I'd rather have a Republican win in November than have "closet Republican" fraud Nye win again. Hopefully a democrat can challenge him. If he's re-elected I'll loose all respect for democrat voters.
Mr Whimp
Glenn, I will not vote for you again. You are spineless. Why did you run against Thelma Drake? You've done pretty much exactly what she would have. You copped out on Healthcare. And if you think your votes will gain you Republican support, you are really not very smart. Republicans will toss you out without a second thought. Now you've lost the support of the democrats. Good bye.
OH SNAP !! The bill passed,
OH SNAP !! The bill passed, hey Glenn I guess you bet on the wrong side, politicaly you will pay a heavy price for your vote, I wonder if you will switch parties....hmm... no matter, see you at the polls in November
that was my first reaction, but on second thought...
Nye may have played the hand he was given quite adroitly. I was very disappointed by his no vote. However, I think come this election Democrats
and independent voters may reevaluate, especial when you consider the opposition. For the most part Nye has been a rational, thoughtful representative and he is still the more qualified than the contenders for his seat.
I am 27 years old. At the
I am 27 years old. At the age of 25 I had to file for bankruptsy becuase of medical bills I had due to insurance NOT covering me becuase of pre existing conditions when I fell off my parents insurance. Noone at my age should have to go through this in order to just simply LIVE. My mother passed away three years ago, becuase she couldnt afford health insurance, and the medications to control her diabetes and got an infection. Perhaps she would still be alive today if this had been done generations before. I am very glad that the uninsured will now have a chance to have their lives in order.
You do understand...
that there are no provisions to cap insurance rates?
Sure, you're going to have insurance, even with your pre-existing condition...but there's nothing to stop that insurance company from jacking up your rates to cover you.
This is the kind of reform that was needed. But it wasn't in this bill.
Nice cramming through a reform that didn't have the right reforms.
You Dont Understand
We do understand - we have the power to send our congress people back and make the appropriate amendments that are needed. We know that we can't get everything in an initial vote, that is why our government is established the way that it is - so that "We the People" have the power to push our elected officials to continue to the work on behalf of the American People. Now is the time for the American people to continue to work to improve the bill by making the Congress people do their jobs.
sorry to hear that katie
Well at least those things wont happen in the future now, because now we have a Congress and a President that actually cares about the issues facing Americans everyday.
YES WE DID!
THE BILL HAS PASS!
WE DID IT!!!!
We did it!!! The Republicans complained about how much this Health Care Reform Bill would cost. They hate spending money on average Americans. Yet they have no problem spending billions and billions of dollars to quench their war monguering appetites and help out their wealthy buddies on Wall Street. The Democrats rose above greedy Republicans and passed the bill! This is the last nail in the coffin of the Republican Party. Too bad for Republicans, the healthcare can't fix the state of their pathetic party.
But the...
Democrats have no problem spending the money of average Americans.
Tax and spend. Make the good, hard working middle class(these people already have health care) pay for everything.
For once, you people should try taking it upon yourselves to make good for yourselves. A government that gives you everything will have no problem taking it away.
Once a government has you dependent on them, your liberty is lost.
people make me laugh
While health care needs reform this isn't the way for it to happen. Why don't people do some research on this dang health care bill and you will realize it's garbage. They can come up with a much better way of reforming our health care than this rush job. Come on people actually do a little reading. I know you love the new Jesus Obama, but everything the dang guy does and says isn't the greatest thing in the world.
He Followed The Money Trail...Plain & Simple
Over half of the bankrupcies in this country are health care related..The system is broke and this guy sides with the classes as opposed to the masses. The masses will answer you back soon enough unless you pull out the LBJ speech "will not seek nor will I accept". Face the facts Mr. Nye you are done in this town.
I am hoping a Democrat will step up and take you on.
Set Your Speed Dial Glenn: Mayflower Movers 800-241-1321
The Health Care System
We NEED CHANGE!
Fear of Government
I understand your fear of governmental control, but WE allow how much the government controls us. We are voters and the concept of popular sovereignty is engrained in the Constitution. And rugged individualism and "social darwinism" (which is what you are alluding to) is mythological projection; Ayn Rand was a fraud.
Thw "We" just...
added a whole lot more governmental control.
Congrats on that!
we do
If we have so much control over the Government then why is this bill going to pass when the majority of Americans are against it.
Majority are for Health Care Reform
You are out of touch, most Americans want health care reform, the noise you hear is from a group of folks that are shown all over the TV by Mainstream Media who want to control the conversation and coerced people into voting against their interests. I am a Middle Class American, and we need this bill, because there are too many Americans sitting in the Emergency Room, there are too many doctors, just calling for test after test that folks don't need just to raise their pay. We need a stop to this foolishness and we need Doctors to do their jobs without the crap, the insurance companies to do their jobs without the crap and the American people to primarily focus on preventative care to keep costs down. We all have a part to play and if we are honest and ethical in the end the best of the Health Care system will prevail. I want these Americans to begin to pay for health care even if it is at a cost lower than mine, people will have more pride if they have access to health care and are paying customers. let everyone take a part and reduce costs.
I'm sure
Republicans will be gracious in defeat. I've heard to show there are no hard feelings, they are going to offer Harry Reid and Obama jobs shining shoes in the Capitol restrooms.