69°
forecast

Need to be in a private club? Don't pay dues with our money.

Posted to: Kerry Dougherty Opinion

How nice for Norfolk's school superintendent.

While many of his students are eating free and reduced lunches, their parents hitting up charities for school supplies and some of his teachers struggling to pay their bills, Richard Bentley can enjoy Thursday Lobster Nights in a private, glass-enclosed dining room with breathtaking views of the Elizabeth River, thanks to a membership at the Town Point Club paid for by taxpayers. (Bentley must pay for his own food if he's there for pleasure, but the membership itself was a gift.)

I know, I know. The $1,300-a-year Town Point Club was part of the benefits package the School Board assembled to lure him to Norfolk from El Paso, Texas.

Shame on them for offering it.

Perks for public employees should never include private club memberships.

Last week we learned that a handful of city employees in Virginia Beach, Norfolk and Chesapeake had private club memberships, courtesy of taxpayers. The most glaring was at the Beach, where the economic development director belongs to the Cavalier Golf & Yacht Club, with its $18,000 initiation fee and $400 monthly dues - courtesy of the public.

Unrepentant city honchos defended this wanton waste of money by insisting that important city business can best be conducted in exclusive clubs.

So let's at least give Norfolk's School Board points for candor.

When he was contacted by Pilot reporter Steven Vegh, board Chairman Kirk Houston didn't try to spin Bentley's membership as anything but an attractive layer of icing on a benefits cake.

"I simply saw it as a perk of the job," Houston said. "I truly think that when you hire persons at that level of responsibility, that you want to try to get some of the best in the business and want to offer them attractive packages."

When I caught up with him Monday, Houston said board members would be discussing the membership with the superintendent to determine whether it's something they want to pay for in future years.

Makes you wonder why they didn't rethink this expenditure before it hit the newspaper.

At a time when the school district was freezing wages, eliminating jobs and cutting its budget to the bone, the board had no business tossing a private club membership into a new employee contract.

This has been going on for years.

When I talked with Bentley on Monday, he pointed out that his predecessors, Stephen C. Jones and John O. Simpson, were both given memberships at Town Point.

"I didn't ask for it. I didn't even know what the Town Point Club was," Bentley said of its inclusion in his contract. "I thought, 'Well, OK, if it's there.' "

Here's the odd thing about the membership: Bentley said that when he was negotiating the terms of his employment, he asked whether the district would be paying for his personal membership in professional organizations.

The answer was no.

So Bentley now springs for his own dues in the American Association of School Administrators, at a cost of about $500.

Think about it. The same board that won't pay dues to organizations that would presumably aid an educator's performance is happy to stroke a check for a private social club that serves $32 filet mignon and $25 crab cakes.

Looks like a case of misplaced priorities.

Here's a question for all public employees who let taxpayers buy them private club memberships:

Did it ever occur to you to just say no?

 

Kerry Dougherty, (757) 446-2306, kerry.dougherty@cox.net

COMMENTS ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here; comments do not reflect the views of The Virginian-Pilot or its websites. Users must follow agreed-upon rules: Be civil, be clean, be on topic; don't attack private individuals, other users or classes of people. Read the full rules here.
- Comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the report violation link below it.

Look at the Pilot first...

I see no problem with Mr. Bentley getting a perk that allows him membership at Norfolk’s Town Point Club. Perhaps his leadership will help Norfolk City Public Schools move towards a better direction. Many civic contacts that might help the school system can be made there, so Kerry lay off. Perhaps a little digging at the Pilot; with the taking away of holidays, retiree medical, the pension plan and the erosion of the core values might make for better reading. I wonder how much sacrifice the Leadership at the Pilot has made for the betterment of the company.
Blessings

Pay or perk?

If a private, paid parking place or a paid cell phone were made part of your salary vs an equal amount in wages, would you turn them down as a misuse of your employer's funds? I see no real difference here, in the case of the superintendent. As for the VB high-end perks, if the net result is on the plus side of the balance sheet, then I also see no problem there. Let's see if the conclusion will bear our weight, before jumping to it.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Please note: Threaded comments work best if you view the oldest comments first.

More articles from: Kerry Dougherty rss feed    Opinion rss feed   


Toolbox