The Virginian-Pilot
©
Everything seemed ordinary about the day that changed everything.
Mario Blanco scheduled some work on his truck at the dealership. Daughter Raven, 8, had a dentist appointment, a routine cleaning and cavity check late that morning.
It was March 9, 2007, a Friday. Blanco dropped his truck off at 9:30, then joined Raven and her mother for the trip to the dentist.
The Chesapeake family would get an early start to the weekend.
But it never really came.
Raven stopped breathing in the dental chair.
Blanco bent on the floor of the waiting room as medics took her away.
Today, a tree spills shade and shadows across a heart-shaped headstone that depicts Raven's smile from one of her last school pictures. It is among Blanco's favorite images of the child who'd looked just like him.
That first year, he bled his grief by the rectangle of faded grass at Forest Lawn Cemetery in Norfolk. When all else felt wrong, the grave site felt right.
Blanco had begun his family later in life. He'd traveled from Long Island to California to Texas and back home again before settling in Virginia in his mid-30s. He started a construction company and met his wife, Robin, who in 1998 gave birth to their first child, Raven. Another daughter followed, then a son, and they lived a comfortable, happy life.
Until that day.
Nearly four years have passed, and still Blanco visits the grave so often he keeps a lawn chair in the back of his truck.
In October, her grave was decorated with a purple, friendly-faced ghost. In December, the Blancos placed ornaments on the tree's bare limbs.
There are dozens of mementos year round: A ceramic dog, an angel figurine, an elephant-shaped cup, Raven's bicycle helmet, a tin of tiny souvenirs Blanco picks up on family trips.
One shivering-cold day in late fall, Blanco, now 55, stood at her headstone and wondered how March 9, 2007, could feel like both yesterday and a hundred years ago.
He pulled up the hood on his tie-dyed sweatshirt. There was a mist in the air and in his eyes. He shook his head. "After a while, people just forget. I don't want people to forget."
This is how Blanco remembers it.
He and Robin and Raven arrived at the dentist with a few minutes to spare. The staff gave the 8-year-old some stickers and a pink ring with googly eyes as she waited, then an oral sedative.
She'd had it before; it would keep her awake but help her relax as she waited with her parents in the lobby.
But something seemed different this time, Blanco said. She commented on the sedative's sour taste, then became fidgety.
The staff escorted Raven to her room. But first, she handed Blanco the pink ring.
Hold my eyes, she told him. I love you.
A couple of patients left as they waited. Another one came in.
Why is there an ambulance outside, the new patient asked the receptionist.
Someone in the back stopped breathing, she said.
Raven was the only one still there. Robin ran to her.
It was chaotic, Blanco said. Paramedics. Police.
The police restrained them as an unresponsive Raven left in an ambulance.
Blanco said he will never know the intricacies of what went wrong.
The medical examiner concluded Raven died from complications of dental sedation. It was ruled accidental.
A year later, the Virginia Board of Dentistry alleged that Raven's dentist had failed to perform a pre-operative assessment, obtain an updated health history, continuously monitor Raven's blood pressure, properly document vital signs and proficiently handle emergencies and complications. He was summoned to an informal conference in Richmond, where the dental board concluded that his record-keeping was inadequate. The board cleared him of all other wrongdoing and ordered the dentist to complete seven hours of continuing education and risk management, according to its records.
The Blancos filed a civil suit in Virginia Beach Circuit Court. Months passed, then years. The case was settled out of court in 2009, and the terms were kept confidential.
Blanco had to get on with life.
Twice, he traveled to South Africa, where he had business connections. Struck by the poverty of children he saw in the streets, he handed out 100 soccer balls. His reward was smile-crinkled faces, little hands clinging proudly to something of their own.
He felt alive.
Later, he donated $10,000 for a groundbreaking on a recreation and worship center for the children there. He equipped them with four months of dental hygiene products.
Back in Virginia, Blanco laid the groundwork for a charitable organization in Raven's name. He put another $10,000 into a black-tie fundraiser to kick it off.
The Raven Maria Blanco Foundation would advocate emergency preparedness in dental offices across the country. It would petition dental associations in every state. It would try to get automated external defibrillators in dental facilities that offer free and discounted services - and to schools and parks and wherever else they were lacking.
On a smaller scale, it would provide tooth-shaped "comfort pillows" for young patients to clutch during visits to the dentist.
When Blanco hands out the pillows, he talks about Raven. He talks about how important it is for dentists to be prepared for emergencies.
He wants her death to save a life.
Drownings and gunfire claim more young lives than dental emergencies, but such deaths have occurred at least once a year since 1996.
Nineteen children died in that 14-year span, based on unofficial counts.
There is no formal reporting system, said Larry Sangrik, a dentist who lectures nationally on emergency preparedness in the dental profession and keeps track of the issue. He and others rely mostly on media reports.
Deaths seem to be on the rise; eight of the 19 occurred in the past two years. A majority died from complications of dental sedation - which dental associations still consider overwhelmingly safe if done properly.
"Where I see a great shortfall in the profession as a whole is most are not equipped to assist a non-breathing patient," Sangrik said.
In May, Blanco read about the death of a 6-year-old Richmond boy named Jacobi Hill.
He was getting cavity fillings and caps; he went into cardiac arrest after a breathing tube was removed, according to media reports.
Blanco went to Jacobi's funeral.
Then he hired someone to run Raven's foundation full-time. If it was left to him, he said, they would get nowhere fast.
Nicole Cunha, his niece, had the time and know-how. By fall, she'd joined forces with Sangrik and the Institute of Medical Emergency Preparedness. She wants every dentist to adopt the institute's concept known as the Six Links of Survival - a checklist that includes a plan, a manual, mock drills and the equipment and medications to handle emergencies.
Cunha oversaw the creation of a public service announcement featuring Sangrik and Blanco. She will ship out 200 this week to dental associations, boards, malpractice and anesthetic companies and dental vendors.
Sangrik will lead a Virginia Dental Association-endorsed course on emergency preparedness in Richmond this spring.
It is called the Raven Maria Blanco Foundation Lecture.
Blanco believes it will save a life.
For more information about the Raven Maria Blanco Foundation, visit www.rmbfinc.org.
Pilot writer Jennifer Jiggetts contributed to this report.
Kristin Davis, (757) 222-5131, kristin.davis@pilotonline.com

Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Facebook
Twitter
Google
Yahoo
My Granddaughter is another victim
My Granddaughter Marissa Kingery died in Ohio on January 3rd, 2011. She like Raven went to the dentist. She went to Dr. Henry Mazorow on December 21, 2010. to have two baby teeth pulled and a third worked on. The dentist put her under general anethesia. She never woke up. Marissa lingered in a coma at Rainbow babies and Children hospital for nearly two weeks. She died on January 3rd 2011.
I have many questions? Why this 81 year old dentist was practicing general anethesia in his office, after he had a wrongful death case against him in 1997? Why the Dental Board in Ohio did not monitor his practice? I wonder if he had emergency procedures in place, and trained staff. I have nightmares about her last moments. Changes need to be made now!
AWARE NOW
WOW.U dnt knw how surreal it was 4 me 2 read ths article.I just took my 20 yr old daughter named Raven 2 have her wisdom teeth remvd on Jan 16th, the day this story ran.I am shakng now as I type.My daughter 2 was sedated (without compl) but thanks 2 this article Im now aware of the proper procedures that should and did take place in her care.I did notice that they monitored her oxy levls, bp, etc pre-op and post-opp.I was there til they askd me 2 leave and i retrnd 2 her room 20 min ltr once it was ovr.She was stil being monitored by an asst 4 anther 10 min or so. I askd ?'s cuz she was shaking and cold and i wanted to kno what was wrong.I am so sorry for the loss of your beautiful Raven but your article will save lives and make us AWARE!
If I remember correctly
the Virginian-Pilot reported at the time of this tragedy that the father stated that he planned no litigation in the case because he knew the dentist, who was devastated, had meant no harm and that Raven had been so fond of him. How sad that somehow his mind was changed, even if the money is to be used for what is probably a good cause. It is no wonder that medical professionals must make every decision with an eye toward the possibility of a law suit.
what an ugly insinuation
i don't suppose it ever occurred to you that more was learned over time?
there was absolutely nothing helpful or positive to be found in your comment unless you were aiming to be the perfect example of one who really ought to keep their opinions to themselves.
http://www.rmbfinc.org/
As a close friend of Mario & Robin, I am amazed at their Courage and Committment in support of preveting any future tragedies like Raven's to happen to other families. I encourage everyone that reads this tragic story to go to www.rmbfinc.org (Raven Maria Blanco Foundation) and make a financial contibution in support of this cause. I have done so.
Sad Story
What a sad and terrible tragedy this family had to endure. It is good that he used his pain to help others in need. I wish his organization the best of luck and hope they are able to prevent tragedies like this from occurring in the future. I would not think twice about sedation if that is what the Dr. said before reading this. Now I would say no way, especially if my kids are involved!
i find the comments here
i find the comments here both surprising and, particularly on a day set aside to remind us of the importance of service, disheartening.
those of you who feel cheated by the lack of detail here might try doing a little research. this tragedy took place several years ago and has been reported on in detail before. it seems to me that today's report was not about the loss of raven, but rather, the legacy her family courageously carries forward in her honor.
seeing as how we are the beneficiaries of their dedication, i would like to say, simply, thank you.
Raven & her foundation
What seems lost in many of the comments is the positive steps this family is trying to achieve after their daughter's death. It is easy to criticize the dentist for sedating this child. It is also easy to criticise the parents for consenting to the sedation. For whatever reasons, those were the decisions that were made by both parties at the time.
That's not the point. The point is that this family, despite their ongoing grief is trying to make a positive influence on the dental profession by increasing awareness about medical emergency preparedness.
Whether you agree or disagree about following their dentist's recommendation about sedating their daughter, you must commend the Blanco's efforts to protect others through their foundation.
It seems that the father said it was okay & the doctor Overdosed
From the whole story:
Dr. Hechtkopf had given the child 1300 mg of chloral hydrate and 30 mg of hydroxyzine, according to dental board hearings on the matter. The autopsy showed Raven had a blood concentration of 24 mg/L of chloral hydrate -- three times the average range -- which the medical examiner considered lethal.
“She was very afraid about going to the dentist.”
— Maria Blanco, Raven Blanco's aunt
"She was very afraid about going to the dentist," Maria Blanco told DrBicuspid.com. "She was even afraid to brush her teeth."
"So he [Mario] thought it would make it less stressful for her," she said. The girl had not eaten prior to the procedure, as Dr. Hechtkopf had instructed, Maria Blanco recalled.
And Nitrous was also used...
The girl died from "complications of dental sedation," the medical examiner said. In addition to chloral hydrate and hydroxyzine, nitrous oxide was also administered.
The dental board cited Dr. Hechtkopf for failing to have adequate clinical documentation of the girl's sedation record, specifically noting that her "vital signs and pulse oximetry readings were absent or poorly documented prior to the onset of the emergency event."
http://www.drbicuspid.com/index.aspx?sec=nws&sub=rad&pag=dis&ItemId=304905&wf=37
So it seems that this is a safe procedure. This doctor ODd the girl and failed to keep good vitals. So the dentist is the one to blame, not the medication.