73°
forecast

Beach council led the way in bleeding public drop by drop

Posted to: Kerry Dougherty Opinion

I was wrong. I admit it. Looks like I missed the big picture.

Faithful readers will recall several rants from last winter against new trash fees that Virginia Beach was noodling.

I argued - futilely, it turned out - that trash collection was a core city service and should continue to be funded as it always had, through property taxes. I predicted that the inauguration of garbage fees could lead to other innovative levies: Crime fees, for instance, for anyone who calls a cop. Stretcher taxes, for anyone who needs an ambulance. Cheesewagon charges, for kids who ride the bus to school.

I also argued that it was wrong for the city to pick the pockets of its poor, taxpaying schlumps who were simply trying to tread water in this rotten economy.

Naturally, I was ignored.

City politicians smelled new money and merrily voted to impose the trash tax, beginning in January.

It's been five months since that decision, and I now see the wisdom in it. Looks like the politicians were only trying to prepare us. They wanted to soften the blow for citizens when private enterprise began clobbering us with new and inventive charges.

By trying to pretend that trash collection had been a freebie until now and that anyone who balked at paying 10 bucks a month for this service was a cheapskate, Resort City honchos were laying the groundwork for what banks are getting ready to do now: charge debit card fees.

Bank executives are trying to convince the public that debit cards have been free all along. They want us to believe that $5 a month is a bargain for the privilege of electronically accessing our own money.

It was inevitable, I suppose.

Once Washington capped the so-called "swipe fees" that banks could charge merchants on debit purchases, the bankers had to find that lost loot somewhere else.

Guess where they looked? To those of us who threw away our checkbooks ages ago in favor of debit cards.

Never mind that electronic transfers undoubtedly save banks tons of money and reduce paperwork. Never mind that banks have been miserly with interest on savings for years. Never mind that many of us have our paychecks deposited directly into our accounts, giving bankers the use of billions of our dollars week after week.

The industry says debit cards were a freebie. We know they weren't.

Bank of America has emerged as the villain. But it's simply the first bank to announce the change. Others already are following suit. Before long, this will be just another $5, or more, that vanishes from our accounts every month.

Of course, these new fees may give other struggling businesses ideas. Perhaps dry cleaners will begin charging hanger fees. After all, they've been giving us those wires for years.

Can supermarket bag fees be far behind? Those flimsy plastic sacks cost money.

Restaurants, which already coerce diners into paying for the luxury of having food delivered to the table, may want to charge for other extras as well. Water, for instance. Cutlery. Napkins.

Next thing you know, employers may start to collect cubicle rent from office workers. Isn't it enough to have a job, without expecting employers to give you a free place to work?

As we look to the future and ponder other taxes and fees coming our way, I'm glad to live in Virginia Beach, where city honchos cared enough to get us ready.

Kerry Dougherty, (757) 446-2306, kerry.dougherty@cox.net

COMMENTS ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here; comments do not reflect the views of The Virginian-Pilot or its websites. Users must follow agreed-upon rules: Be civil, be clean, be on topic; don't attack private individuals, other users or classes of people. Read the full rules here.
- Comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the report violation link below it.

Charge for plastic grocery bags

Interesting you mentioned this. I discovered while visiting Washington DC this summer that grocery stores, drug stores, etc do charge per bag now!

Black listed?

Am i being blacklisted agian?

Greener pastures

If you think you have it bad, I moved to upstate NY for the sake of my first child in order to have a mother at home in an affordable home. The rest of what happened I did not expect......but to keep on point here....trash fees of 10 bucks is not bad, try 2.50 per bag of trash at the transfer site that you have to take it to every week. Consider 10 bucks a month a cheap hit. At least your population density absorbs much of the need for higher taxation like here. My parents pay close to 500 dollars a month in combined school tax and property tax on a home assessed at around 270K. Taxes are on the way up for you down there too, its just a matter of time!

replace council

Replace City Council with the members of the school board. They know how to save money. They can pick the next school board so we can trust them. Then both council and school board will know how to save money and council won't simply stteal the school board's money and raise their credit limit as a way to pay them back.

DC has...

DC has a plastic bag tax that is collected by retailers...
...YEP, a nickel apiece. No joke.

BP in DC

Good. Every place should tax

Good. Every place should tax you for using plastic bags, so maybe I won't see them blowing across streets, stuck in gutters, on the beach, etc. I saw this in Europe and it only took one time paying to rethink my habit.

Just The Start

I agree that the trash tax is only the start. The city of Va. Beach has made some unwise business investments over the past 15 years, and the taxpayers are on the hook for these costs. Starting in Januray, my neighbors and I plan to put our recycle containers out every two weeks, but they will be empty, the recycleables will be in the trash cans. The city can hire another bureaucrat to pick the garbage from the recycles (a suitable job for most any current city department manager). Way to go GOP-controlled city council, raising taxes on the working citizens in a tough economy. There's no hypocrisy there! Where is the city GOP on this? In November 2012, let's all trash the incumbents.

GOP?

At the local level of government party affiliation is nothing but a moniker and has little bearing on policy and ideals. All candidates seek monies from businesses and corps, because that is where the money is, and you have to have money to run for office.
By the way I did vote thumbs up on your posting.

This is what happens when you invite the Government

into every crook and cranny of your life. Everytime you vote for a new bill, or vote someone into office that wants to give you "free" things (like health care, welfare, etc).

This country has voted its self into poverty, yet you still have the bleeding hearts screaming for more, and cheering when the poor get their cars booted, or when they get their land taken from them.

Each and every one of you should be afraid of what's next, and ashamed of the position you've put this great country in.

Look forward to every penny you earn going to the Government while you stand in line at the food stamp counter only to be told you make to much to afford to eat.

Scratching my head....

Well we got this new trash fee that if you don't pay it they'll shut your water off (I have a key to turn it back on if necessary) but here's what I can't figure out:

In the past ten years the population of Virginia Beach has pretty much flattened out, school enrollment has declined, we have cut positions, pay and benefits to city workers and we haven't seen a marked increase in police, fire, rescue or other core services....

So why has the municipal budget DOUBLED in ten years?

Seems to me the answer for everything is more government spending on things the government shouldn't be spending on....

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Please note: Threaded comments work best if you view the oldest comments first.

More articles from: Kerry Dougherty rss feed    Opinion rss feed   


Toolbox