74°
forecast

HRT to use taxicabs for some Handi-Ride customers

Posted to: News Traffic - Transportation

Some customers of the Handi-Ride curb-to-curb service for disabled people will be picked up in taxicabs instead of the small, lift-equipped buses they've become accustomed to, starting in early December.

To control spiraling costs for paratransit service, Hampton Roads Transit has modified its contract with MV Transportation to allow the use of less expensive taxis for customers who are ambulatory and do not require extra assistance. About 40 percent of trips, mostly at night and on weekends, will be moved to cabs, HRT estimates.

Additionally, some clients may experience longer trip times because the changes include extending the maximum ride time from 60 minutes to 90 minutes to allow MV to carry more passengers per trip.

HRT estimates the changes will result in reducing costs by about $500,000 a year, or about $1.25 million for the remainder of its contract with MV, a national company based in Fairfield, Calif.

The savings are actually a cost avoidance; the demand for the service, and therefore the cost, has been growing steadily. Under the new contract, HRT's Handi-Ride costs are expected to continue to rise, but not as much.

HRT's goal, said Philip Shucet, its president, is to maintain reasonable services and to better manage growing costs.

When MV began running Handi-Ride for HRT in 2008, 700 to 750 daily trips were taken, said Andy Steed, MV's general manager for Hampton Roads. Today, it's 1,000 to 1,050 per day.

Over the past three years, HRT's cost for the service has grown from $6.6 million to about $8.5 million annually.

Keith Johnson, HRT's superintendent of paratransit and bus operations, said the aging population is contributing to the growth in demand for services. Cuts in transportation services by other agencies and a spike in dialysis patients are also driving the numbers up.

So far this year, about 70 new customers a month are certified as eligible for the service. Last year, it was about 120 a month. Overall, about 1,800 clients use the service.

HRT is also encouraging paratransit riders to use regular bus service, which would be free for them and a personal care attendant. The transit agency will be offering training for customers to transition to buses.

Johnson said about 20 percent of current Handi-Ride customers could use buses: "We will not be forcing anybody to make the change to bus. If you qualify for Handi-Ride, you always can use Handi-Ride."

Johnson noted, however, that those who do switch would save money and could be more independent because advance reservations are not required.

Some customers are anxious about the changes.

"Most wonder, 'Does it meet the law and will it be as accessible to everyone as it was before?' " said Rena Lewis, who works for the Endependence Center and rides Handi-Ride.

Lewis said some people can get into cabs without difficulty, but may have a problem getting out.

The fleet of paratransit buses will be trimmed from 87 to 33. MV has given notice to its local workforce that 56 drivers and six office staff members will be laid off. That's close to half of its local workforce of 135.

Federally mandated Handi-Ride offers transportation to qualified customers for trips that start and end within three-quarters of a mile of a regular, or fixed, transit route. The $3 charge per one-way trip is double the regular bus fare.

Handi-Ride is available by reservation only. Appointments for rides must be made one to three days in advance.

Debbie Messina, (757) 446-2588, debbie.messina@pilotonline.com

COMMENTS ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here; comments do not reflect the views of The Virginian-Pilot or its websites. Users must follow agreed-upon rules: Be civil, be clean, be on topic; don't attack private individuals, other users or classes of people. Read the full rules here.
- Comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the report violation link below it.

on the PAC Board

i am on the paratransit board for HRT. The taxis have a low complaint factor, and an 89% on time performance- they also have had 0 trips over 90 minutes- all in all they are doing very well-

on the PAC Board

i am on the paratransit board for HRT- the taxi companies have a very low complaint rate and an 89% on time performance- there will always be isolated issues, however all in all it is positive-

HRT/Handle Rides

To whom this may concern:

I am very concern about my sister missing two very important doctors appointment in two day . I understanding that your company or companies have cut back because of funds, and using other services. But your customer are suffering. Her first bad experience where Thursday Dec 15, 2011. She was pick up late and drop off at the wrong building and waited four hours to be picked back up again, and did not get home until 8pm that evening. The second Doctor appointment December 16 at 2:30, she did not go at all, because her ride came to pick her up at 2:20 to late. My sister is in a wheel chair, she is a diabetic and was just diagnose with bladder cancer. These appointments were pre-posted before her surgery. Thank You.

Great Point

A great point made by an earlier poster, I too, thought the purpose of mass transit was to reduce the number of vehicles on the road, not add to it. HRT's inept management and its lack of credible oversight by its appointed Board of Directors shines once again. I give Mr. Shucet a lot of credit for fixing light rail, but there are still deep issues with HRT's bloated upper-management ranks that result in inefficient services and short-changing the public. Then again, what should we expect from an agency that has hired one of the light rail consultants to be the Chief of Planning and Development?

sad comments

This is a federal mandate if you read the article, so it is passed down to us to pay out of our tax dollars.

Regardless, I would hate to be the person who has to rely on this service. No one chooses to be disabled and to lose their independence.

I assume that the taxi companies are private contractors, which makes sense since they will be out and about anyway.

A great idea

I've got a great idea. An HRT Light Rail line that only handi riders can ride. It'll go absolutely no where yet costs millions of dollars. It'll share the same line as the current light rail and even have hadicapped parking. This idea is a joke and so is the taxi idea. These buses are E350 Ford vans that have wheelchair lifts. They carry those unable to drive to doctor's appointments and other areas they couldn't access on their own. Yet everytime I see one, its sitting(engine running) half empty, and the drivers reading,sleeping, or away from the vehicle. So no wonder HRT is losing money.

handi-ride. . .

...yet another failed government subsidized transportation business that has ballooned into monstrous misuse and deficit.

Perhaps Chesapeake schools

Perhaps Chesapeake schools could adopt this measure! Every morning I see bus after empty bus driving through our neighborhood to transport one special needs child. This is going on all over the district. What a waste of money.

What am I missing?

Why is it more expensive to operate one bus with one driver that carries several people than to operate several cabs with several drivers that carries 1 or 2 people?

Wasting more?

More taxis running around vs. one bus surely is going to cost more. Who are these taxis? Commercial or HRT? With HRT involved it will be another boondoggle.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Please note: Threaded comments work best if you view the oldest comments first.

More articles from: News rss feed    Traffic - Transportation rss feed   


Toolbox