68°
forecast

In plain language: Voters should know their English

Posted to: Kerry Dougherty Opinion

Lemme get this straight.

To become a citizen of the United States, you must – except in a few exceptional circumstances – be able to “read, write and speak basic English.” Yet the Department of Justice this week ordered 248 localities in 25 states to print ballots in foreign languages, based on census data that detected hot spots of non-English speakers.

Virginia is one of those states. Lucky us.

Seems the most recent census showed an explosion in the number of Spanish speakers living in Fairfax County, so the commonwealth has been ordered to prepare for bilingual voting in its largest jurisdiction – even though the Constitution of Virginia requires that all voters be U.S. citizens.

Honestly. You couldn’t make it up.

This expansive order goes beyond bilingual ballots. Election officials in Richmond now must translate into Spanish about 27 different election-related forms – from voter registration applications to absentee ballot applications to polling place signs. God help them if anything is lost in translation.

The paperwork and posters will be printed and distributed throughout the county. All to accommodate what must be a tiny percentage of voters who lack the rudimentary mastery of English that’s necessary to negotiate a ballot.

How much will this bilingual blowout cost? No one knows. Yet. No one in Washington seems to care. And why should they? This is just one more unfunded mandate from the feds.

Fairfax, in case you didn’t know, is the most populous locality in Virginia, with more than a million residents and 689,813 registered voters.

According to the census, roughly 27 percent of Fairfax County’s residents are foreign-born, and 15.6 percent are of Hispanic or Latino origin.

Now, because a bunch of bean counters in D.C. spotted Spanish speakers in Fairfax – and it appears there’s no way to know for certain whether these folks are even citizens – the county is being forced to produce Spanish-language ballots.

File this heavy-handed move under the general heading of “unintended consequences” or “what happens when good laws go bad.”

The law in question is the Voting Rights Act, signed into law in 1965 by President Lyndon Johnson. It was designed to put an end to a variety of discriminatory practices that intentionally suppressed the votes of some minorities, especially African Americans.

“This act flows from a clear and simple wrong,” Johnson said at the signing. “Millions of Americans are denied the vote because of their color. This law will ensure them the right to vote. The wrong is one which no American, in his heart, can justify.”

Well put, LBJ.

Fast-forward 46 years and this noble law has been twisted by politically correct politicians and federal apparatchiks to mean that citizens who have somehow failed to achieve a basic proficiency in English have a right to voting materials in their native tongues. At public expense, of course.

Fact is, in 1965, racists, thugs and election officials were acting – sometimes in concert – to interfere with the basic rights of many American citizens to vote.

In 2011, a small number of citizens have hampered their own ability to vote by failing to learn another language. There’s a simple solution for them: English classes.

Kerry Dougherty, (757) 446-2306, kerry.dougherty@cox.net

COMMENTS ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here; comments do not reflect the views of The Virginian-Pilot or its websites. Users must follow agreed-upon rules: Be civil, be clean, be on topic; don't attack private individuals, other users or classes of people. Read the full rules here.
- Comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the report violation link below it.

Jussayin...

People in the following categories are exempt from the English portion of the citizenship test:

•50 years old or older and you've lived in the US as permanent resident for at least 20 years
•55 years old or older and you've lived in the US as permanent resident for at least 15 years
•65 years old or older and you've lived in the US as permanent resident at least 10 years

Therefore, we do indeed have bona fide citizens who do not speak English and are entitled to vote. I guess we have to hope they stay current on the issues through the US hispanic papers and broadcasts.

It would also help if the US actually HAD an official language. That amendment has never passed.

Looks like

Voter fraud is starting early this selection cycle, hee haw!

Thank you!

I've long thought exactly the same thing. If you can't read basic English, how can you inform yourself of the issues of the day? If you're content to have someone else tell you how to vote, well then, there are many other countries in the world where the ruling elite will do just that. Perhaps one of them would be a better fit as your immigration destination. As for twisting the meaning of legislation for one's own benefit, we see that every day with our local, state, and federal politicians and bureaucrats, don't we?

Read or write basic English

The following paragraph is part of voter registration-much of this is beyond "basic English".

Failure to complete the form properly could result in your registration being delayed or denied. Note that you must provide your social security number, if any, when applying to register to vote in Virginia. Therefore, if you do not provide your social security number, your application for voter registration will be denied. State and local voting officials will use your social security number as a unique identifier to insure that no person is registered in more than one place.

Really? Money is the concern?`

I like how Kerry is worried about how much it may cost, without any figures of course. What about in Minnesota where new, stricter laws will cost the state about $5-$8 million? Or South Carolina, where another nut job governor is spending capital to disinfranchise more voters. OK, they're not Virginia, but if the backwards government in this state had its way, they'd go to any lengths to prevent people that aren't rich and white from voting.
How much money can we waste on frivolous law suits brought on by our Attorney General? Any complaining about that? No, probably not.

So why learn English? Seems like we're a bilingual country now.

I have friends from all over the globe: NATO friends from Europe; Eastern European friends who come here to work and experience our wonderful freedoms; and friends who have come here from China and French-speaking Quebec who struggled to become citizens (something we native-borns take for granted.) France, Germany, Sri Lanka, The Netherlands, Croatia, China, Japan, Korea, Russia -- all my international friends have learned English -- they don't expect every sign and instruction to be in their native languages. Why are we bending over so far to accommodate Spanish-speakers, to the point where we are well on the way to becoming a bilingual country?

Because they're learning

Because they're learning challenged?

Good point

You name the country, the people there respect you more if you make an effort to speak the language of their country. So why shouldn't we expect people that LIVE here speak American English? Forcing another language on this country is not a good idea. All of America's legal documents are written in English. To become a citizen, you do have to pass an English competency exam. If a person can't speak and understand English they shouldn't be allowed to vote.

Amen!

Agreed and well said, Kerry. If you can't speak the native language of a country then you shouldn't be allowed to take part in its benefits or its government. It should be that simple. No one should be allowed to vote if they can't understand the American language, period.

Did you say "the American

Did you say "the American language"?

You don't get a vote.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Please note: Threaded comments work best if you view the oldest comments first.

More articles from: Kerry Dougherty rss feed    Opinion rss feed   


Toolbox