©
This story was compiled from reports by The New York Times and The Washington Post.
KABUL, Afghanistan
A video showing four U.S. Marines urinating on the bodies of three dead Taliban fighters provoked anger and condemnation Thursday in Afghanistan and around the world. U.S. officials said they feared the images could incite anti-U.S. sentiment at a particularly delicate moment in the war effort.
The Obama administration is struggling to keep President Hamid Karzai on its side as it carefully tries to open talks with the Taliban. Yet the video showing such a desecration - a possible war crime - is likely to weaken the U.S. position with both. The Taliban and Karzai were each quick to hold up the images as evidence of U.S. brutality, a message with broad appeal in Afghanistan, where word of the video was slowly spreading Thursday.
Senior military officials in Kabul and at the Pentagon who were scrutinizing the video confirmed it was authentic and that they had identified the Marines as members of the 3rd Battalion, 2nd Marines, all of whom had completed a tour of Afghanistan this fall before returning to base at Camp Lejeune, N.C. The officials did not immediately release their names.
A Marine official told The Washington Post that investigators were questioning two individuals whom they had preliminarily identified as being in the video.
Pentagon officials said the video had been made sometime between March and September 2011, when the Marine battalion was deployed to Helmand province, a strategic Taliban heartland and a center of the opium poppy trade. The officials said they did not know the precise location depicted in the video but they said it had likely been made in the northern part of the province, where the battalion had operated. Seven out of about 1,000 Marines in the battalion were killed during the seven-month deployment.
Pentagon officials said that as far as they knew all four Marines were still on active duty. They said they could identify one of them as a corporal based on his uniform.
The video, posted on public video sharing websites including LiveLeak and YouTube, began ricocheting around international news websites on Wednesday.
Even before the authenticity of the video had been confirmed, expressions of outrage and contrition by Defense Secretary Leon Panetta, Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton and other top officials left no doubt they regarded it as real.
Aware of the video's potential to damage the United States' already shaky image in Afghanistan, Panetta denounced the video as "utterly deplorable" and called Karzai to assure him a full investigation was under way and those responsible would be punished.
"I wanted him to know how grieved we were at what happened here," Panetta said in an interview while traveling to Fort Bliss, Texas. "What I want is an investigation into what happened here, what laws were violated by what took place, who these individuals were."
The video showed four men in the Marines' distinctive sand-colored camouflage uniforms urinating over the three corpses - one covered in blood - splayed on the ground before them. The men joke and jaw with one another, a lewd reference is made, and one is heard to say, "have a great day, buddy."
The Taliban initially indicated the images would not undermine the push toward talks, regarding the video as just more evidence of what they view as U.S. brutality and disrespect for Afghans.
"This is not the first time we see such brutality," a Taliban spokesman, Zabihullah Mujahid, told Reuters.
But later Thursday, in an official statement issued to news outlets, the Taliban dropped its references to the talks and stressed the brutality message.
"We strongly condemn the inhuman act of wild American soldiers, as ever, and consider this act in contradiction with all human and ethical norms," the statement said.
Karzai struck a similar tone - he, too, described the video as "inhuman" - saying in a statement that he was deeply disturbed by the images. He asked the Americans to severely punish anyone found guilty of a crime.
"This act by American soldiers is simply inhuman and condemnable in the strongest possible terms," he said.
The actions of the Marines in the video could amount to a violation of the Geneva Convention, which requires that the bodies of those killed in war be treated honorably.

Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Facebook
Twitter
Google
Yahoo


TALIBAN ARE NOT THE ENEMY??????
Although I do not condone this behavior and wonder why these warriors (yes, they are still warriors)would be stupid enough to put this on tape, I'm quite sure this administration is just itching to throw these warriors into FT. Leavenworth prison along with countless others punished for far less acts on the battlefield. It's amazing to me how we show more concern for the enemy than we do our own military personnel. I'm sorry, wait a minute I forgot the President said the Taliban wasn't our enemy. It kind of makes you wonder why we've spilled so much American blood for a group of people we don't consider our enemy. I'm just over this statist war. Regardless, this was a dumb act.
I'm no fan of the President
but I think you're off the mark here. First off, it was Vice President Biden who said the Taliban isn't our enemy, a point of view with which I disagree, considering they lobbed rockets and mortars my way several times between Christmas Eve and New Year's Day; I don't think they were meant as celebratory fireworks.
Second, I don't believe President Obama is showing more concern for the enemy here than he is for our guys at all. The fact is that what these Marines did endangers everyone in Afghanistan. The recruiting video voice overs write themselves here.
Obama?
Your hatred of Obama weakens your point. Their actions were counter to treaties the US has signed. They counter to US law. They are counter to Afghan law. You will point out that US law and Afghan law are not applicable here, which is correct, but their actions, if reports are accurate, were in violation of USMC rules and the UCMJ. Warriors? Yes, in the sense that barbarian hordes were warriors. Their actions demean everyone serving in uniform honorably.
where was korizi and the afgan military when OBL was living
in the same town as they? They harbor terrorists and claim they know nothing?
OK, we are going to do a witch hunt upon these 4. Will korizi do the same thing in his country? Nope. Will O fly over to Afgan, get off AF1, and grovel at the feet of Korizi? Will he then admit we should never have been here in the first place and that it was all because of Bush's lies? Will he beg for forgiveness, and promise to leave the country?
Anything our boys do, is a direct reflection of their leadership and O is their CIC. O does this to States rights and our constitution. Does it make what these 4 did right. Nope. They should know better. They will be held accountable, yet O sees he has done nothing wrong to us or the States. Figures.
C-in-C?
Just curious, but why is it when bad things happen, Obama is the C-in-C and is to blame, but if things go well, though Obama is the C-in-C, he had no part in it?
Comment deleted
Comment removed for rules violation. Reason: Post continued, repeated
Marine video
I don't suppose Taliban conduct of beheading people, hanging them from bridges, etc. is considered "inhuman" or "desecration of a dead body" by anyone except Americans. As other poster stated, it might not be the best choice for a public relations photo shoot, but before all the Monday morning quarterbacks chime in, WALK IN THE BOOTS OF THESE MARINES ! What have they been through? What have they seen? The Secretary of Defense should calm down and stop with the political- correctness hand-wringing. Warn the troops not to do it again (in front of a camera) and let it go!!
Warn Them?
Their behavior was despicable. Their actions contrary to DoD policy, including USMC regulations. Their actions were probably behavior unbecoming to a US marine. You can't justify misbehavior because the other side is worse - that is part of having a morale high ground. Let them off with a minor warning and you enable every other service member with bad judgment and impulse control problems to do whatever they wish when ever they wish, which would be counter to supporting military discipline and unit cohesion.
You suppose wrong
The desecration of a dead body is not a contest of degrees. Stuff like this is jihadist-recruitment fodder. Fascinating that you paint the issue of body desecration as a PC-driven matter.
Comment deleted
Comment removed for rules violation. Reason: Post continued, repeated