The Virginian-Pilot
©
VIRGINIA BEACH
The City Council stuck with tradition on Tuesday night, voting to keep the private company that's provided lifeguard services at resort-area beaches for decades.
The 7-4 vote to rehire the Virginia Beach Lifesaving Service came despite a city report that said turning lifeguard duties over to the city's Department of Emergency Medical Services would save the city $1.4 million over five years.
Some council members said they were not convinced those savings would pan out, citing, for example, a possible future need for a city building to run the operation.
"We're excited to continue serving Virginia Beach," said Tom Gill, deputy chief for Virginia Beach Lifesaving Service, taking deep breaths after the vote. Right up until the end, at least two council members on the clearly divided body had yet to make up their mind.
Voting to keep the company were Mayor Will Sessoms, Glenn Davis, Bill DeSteph, Harry Diezel, Barbara Henley, John Moss and John Uhrin.
Voting for a city takeover were Vice Mayor Louis Jones, Bob Dyer, Rosemary Wilson and Jim Wood.
City Manager Jim Spore and Emergency Medical Services Chief Bruce Edwards wanted the council to bring lifeguard services in-house.
"We are pleased that the City Council took a serious look at the provision of lifeguard services at the resort beaches and evaluated all the facts before voting this evening," Edwards after the vote in a prepared statement.
Former and current lifeguards packed the City Council chambers, offering testimonials about their work with the company and pleading with the City Council not to make a change.
Some Sandbridge residents said lifeguard service has improved since the Department of Emergency Medical Services took over guarding beaches there from the company in 2009. City officials said they have saved about $111,000 a year by bringing that work in-house.
The city is set to pay Virginia Beach Lifesaving Service $1.45 million this year to guard resort beaches, mainly between Rudee Inlet and 42nd Street. The company will be paid $7.3 million over five years, according to the city.
DeSteph said he voted for the private company because the government should not be taking work from small companies.
Kent Hinnant, president of Virginia Beach Lifesaving Service, and his wife own half the company, and Angela Garcia Mozer, daughter of developer Eddie Garcia Sr., owns the rest.
The city said its lifeguards would have been certified at a higher level for medical emergencies.
"You're talking a higher level of service for less cost," Wood said.
Dyer said the city should take over the work to save money to help chip away at the city's $90 million budget shortfall.
"It's more than money," Sessoms said. "It's about tradition. It's been a great place for young people to be responsible and grow up."
Aaron Applegate, 757-222-5122,aaron.applegate@pilotonline.com
____
Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Facebook
Twitter
Google
Yahoo
cha-ching!
Does VBLS still have exclusive rights to rent out beach chairs at the oceanfront? An all cash business with no way to record purchases except for teenagers at the beach with a pen and paper? seems like a real good way to make an untraceable buck! So, if the city or state tried to come down on you for any of it, they'd be left without any lifeguards to save the precious tourists!
ba- da- bing!
As usual....
As usual the Council goes about something the wrong way.... It is correct that the VBDEMS has NO business in the lifeguard business at the oceanfront.
Having said that, when ANY other private company does work for or with teh City, it is AWARDED through the process of an RFP, or a competitive bidding process. Why should this lifeguard contract have been any different?
The Council should have been looking into ways to save money by putting this out for an RFP, but wait.... tradition and politics wouldn't allow thst.
Sad that politics still run rampant behind the scenes at Virginia Beach City Hall, this was NEVER about money for many of the Council members.
Lifeguard Company
Angela Garcia could not run Ocean Breeze Park when their family were the owners. Hope that can she run the lifeguard company better than the way Ocean Breeze was managed.
investor
I doubt you'd find Angela Garcia anywhere near this place, she's an investor.
Budget shortfall?
"Chip away at 90 Million budget shortfall"?? Maybe if VBEMS started billing insurance and medicare for ambulance transports the city could recoup some funds. And you don't have to get rid of the volunteers to do it. Every city in Hampton Roads charges for this except Va. Beach. With the economy so bad, why isn't this being looked into?
I'm glad to see that VBLS still has the contract. I hate to see Government take away from small businesses.
8 to 12 Million
You are correct! They leave 8 to 12 million a year uncollected every year... Just dumb when they are talking about laying off 640 teachers.